Posted on 06 June 2010.
In the spirit of examining bad calls in sports history, I decided to take a look at a few U. Oklahoma Sooner football games where officials stepped in at crucial moments and altered the outcome of the game. I listed these games from bad to worst. Things I considered how to rank the games: how bad the call was (or calls, actually), what the public’s reaction was, and how the call affected history.
So without further adieu, the three worst calls in OU football history:
NOV. 19, 2005: OU-TEXAS TECH
The crime: It is said that in basketball, a lot can happen in 30 seconds. Well in the final 30 seconds of this 2005 game in Lubbock, Texas, the officials turned 30 seconds into 15 minutes and applied that adage to football.
Three plays were reviewed at the end of Tech’s 13-play drive at SBC Jones Stadium:
• First, a questionable spot on a fourth-down completion. Tech receiver Danny Amendola caught a deflected pass and came down at the OU 24-yard line, but the referees incorrectly placed the ball at the 23, giving the Red Raiders a first down by an inch. A review failed to change the spot.
• Then, Tech quarterback Cody Hodges threw in the end zone to receiver Joel Filani, who bobbled a ball that was never even caught — much less inbounds — yet was initially ruled a touchdown. This time, the review did overturn the call.
• Finally, Taurean Henderson’s 2-yard touchdown run, which came courtesy of side judge Scott Koch. Henderson was awarded the score after being tackled short of the end zone. The tailback run a draw up the middle and, as time expired, was hit by OU linebacker Rufus Alexander. As Henderson fell to the ground, he stretched the football toward the end zone. His final movement while on the ground was to cradle the ball above his head, across the goal line. Koch ran in from the side, pushed his way through players, poked his head into the pile of bodies and then raised his arms to signal a touchdown. The review lasted for several minutes before the officials confirmed their hazy call.
It was declared the worst-officiated game in college football history by Gil LeBreton of the Fort Worth Star-Telegram.
“If the Big 12 is going to have instant replay and ignore it, why bother even reviewing a call?” LeBreton wrote in his blog.
After storming off the field, OU head coach Bob Stoops told reporters he was mad as he’s ever been. However, the animated Stoops who was stomping around the locker room remained calm and composed when addressing the media in his post-game conference.
“Bottom line, they got those calls and we didn’t,” Stoops said. “And they made enough plays to win and we didn’t.”
Former Big 12 Commissioner Kevin Weiberg stood by the replay official’s decision not to overturn the final play.
“I think the replay official did exactly what we have asked him to do,” Weiberg said. “He looked at the video that was available to him and it did not meet the standard of being able to reverse the call.”
The verdict: While this loss hurt, it didn’t prevent OU from reaching a BCS game — the Sooners had already suffered losses to TCU, UCLA and Texas — but it did ended the team’s four-game winning streak and added another painful blemish to tough season. And while the argument can be made that OU should have never put itself into such a tight position (the offense was virtually shut down in the third quarter, allowing Tech to extend its lead), the defense did what it was asked to do: Stop Texas Tech.
All OU had to do was to stop Tech from converting a first down, which it did, and keep Henderson out of the end zone, which it also did. The Sooners won the game of inches, but the officiating crew gave Tech a nudge forward, and gave OU a bitter finish to an exciting game. Clearly the worst officiating performance in the Stoops era. That is, until…
SEPT. 16, 2006: OU-OREGON
The crime: It was a crazy 72 seconds in 2006 at Autzen Stadium that all Sooner fans would rather forget.
Oregon had just scored a touchdown in the fourth quarter of a hard-fought game to narrow OU’s lead to 33-27. With 1:12 left on the clock, the Ducks attempted an onside kick, which was recovered by OU running back Allen Patrick.
To everyone’s amazement, however, the referees signaled Oregon ball. The call was sent to the booth to be reviewed by replay official Gordon Reise, who spent seven minutes missing what everyone else in the world saw: That an Oregon player touched the ball before it went 10 yards. Oh, and not to mention the part where the Sooner recovered the ball, not Oregon.
Despite an incredible amount of video evidence in OU’s favor, the ball was given to Oregon.
To add insult to injury, during the ensuing drive there was a pass interference call against OU that also was reviewed. Although replays showed the ball was tipped, which negates all interference penalties, officials confirmed the penalty. The Ducks got the call, scored on the next play and ended up winning the game.
The Pac-10 acknowledged the Monday after that the kick was touched by an Oregon player before it traveled the required 10 yards, so the ball should have been awarded to the Sooners.
“The fact that the errors on the onside kick altered the outcome of the game is most unfortunate and unsettling,” said Tom Hansen, the then Pac-10 commissioner. “Errors clearly were made and not corrected, and for that we apologize to the University of Oklahoma, [Bob] Stoops and his players.”
Still, OU head coach Bob Stoops called the error unacceptable.
“I’ve made a million mistakes; I’ll make a million more. In each game … there are things I could have done differently or changed. Unlike officials, players and coaches don’t have that opportunity,” Stoops said. “They had an opportunity to get it right, and they chose not to.”
The verdict: The loss was one of two the Sooners suffered during the regular season, and it most likely kept OU from playing in the BCS National Championship. However, even though the officials botched two calls, the Sooners’ fate was still in their hands. The defense should have stopped the Ducks’ touchdown drive and kicker Garrett Hartley should have converted his 44-yard field goal.
So while the officials handed Oregon’s offense more chances than it had earned, OU had last-minute opportunities to walk away victorious. For that, the team must be held accountable. Still, the horrendous officiating robbed the Sooners of what appeared to be an almost wrapped-up road victory.
OCT. 13, 1984: OU-TEXAS
The crime: Barry Switzer may have been upset with many of the calls during the 1984 edition of the Red River Shootout, but it was the call that wasn’t made during Texas’ final drive of the game that sent the OU head football coach into a frenzy.
With OU leading 15-12, Sooners defensive back Keith Stanberry appeared to have picked off Texas quarterback Todd Dodge’s pass in the end zone with seconds remaining. The officiating crew ruled the pass incomplete, saying Stanberry was out of bounds. However, TV replays clearly showed that Stansberry intercepted the pass, had possessions and was inbounds.
On the next play, Texas kicker Jeff Ward booted a 32-yard field goal on the last play to tie the game 15-15 and sent Switzer tripping over his headphone cables while he chased after the referees, seething at the decisive call.
“It’s the most controversial call I’ve ever been involved in,” Switzer said.
The Big Eight Conference later admitted it erred with the call.
“We regrettably were wrong, and it was an official’s error; we feel real bad about it,” said Bruce Finlayson, then the Big Eight supervisor of officials.
But the unacknowledged pick wasn’t the only thing that stunk up the Cotton Bowl that day, the refs also missed a Texas fumble on that final drive.
Switzer later said the officiating crew “actually took the game away from us.”
The verdict: OU had a 4-0 record coming into the Texas game, but the team still went on to lose two games during the season and finish 9-2-1. Still, while it may not have had the drama or the season-altering impact as the debacle in Eugene, Oreg., any time the Sooners are prevented from handing their bitter rivals a defeat is always a travesty.
An argument can be made that if instant replay had been used in 1984, Stanberry’s waived-off interception almost surely would have been overturned. Then again, Oregon’s onside kick and the poor spots against Texas Tech seemed to have enough evidence to reverse the calls.
Around Norman, beating Texas is a measuring stick for how successful a season is, and when the officials took that away from OU in 1984, it left an awfully bitter taste in people’s mouth. Stanberry was inbounds. Not even loyal Longhorns deny it.