Borough council votes down vacating area

By Paul Osolnick

The State College Borough Council voted against vacating a 300-foot long section of North Buckhout Street at its meeting Monday night.

The petition to vacate the area was made by Penn State on July 2, 2009 and a public hearing was held concerning the vacation on August 17, 2009.

Penn State spokeswoman Lisa Powers said the section is an unused part of the street that cuts through property owned by the university.

Powers said the street exists only “on paper” since it is no longer used as a street, and therefore is no longer maintained by the borough.

“This is pretty common,” Powers said. “We’re just asking for [the borough] to turn it over to us… We’ll take care of it.”

The property is the former O.W. Houts & Sons retail store which closed in January of 2008 and was purchased by the university later that year, university officials said.

The university purchased the property and — after demolishing the former store — has still not determined what the land will be used for, Powers said.

Borough Manager Tom Fountaine said the section — or “right-of-way” — has not been open to the public since 1948.

Fountaine said that under the law, if a right-of-way is not opened within 21 years, the public loses some of its rights for the passage. That is when the passage is usually vacated, Fountaine said.

Fountaine said the vacated right-of-way would have been divided evenly between the adjacent property owners, but the property surrounding the right-of-way is owned entirely by the university.

While State College’s borough staff recommended vacating the right-of-way due to a lack of “municipal interest,” the planning commission recommended against the move until the university reveals plans for the properties controlled by the university, Fountaine said.

With several members agreeing with the planning commission, the council voted against the ordinance 5-2.

The council addressed another section of the right-of-way to be vacated. The borough vacated what council members call an “unopened portion of Birch Alley.” The area will be allocated to three residential property owners surrounding the unused alley.

“This is a section of alley that has never been ordained or accepted by the borough,” Fountaine said. “Since it has never been opened, the council has been asked to vacate the alley.”

If the council had not vacated the Birch Alley passage, then the cost of restoring the right-of-way would have fallen on taxpayers.

“If the borough had to start maintaining it again, it would be an expensive and a cost to the public,” Fountaine said. “There’s not a real strong public interest in doing that.”

Read more here: http://www.collegian.psu.edu/archive/2010/07/13/penn_state_obtains_birch_alley.aspx
Copyright 2026 Daily Collegian