Some of my fondest memories of Iowa City are from last summer, when I spent afternoons on the Pedestrian Mall, eating frozen yogurt, reading library books, and mingling with all the artists, musicians, and writers who had just hopped off a train. Many of these travelers had signs perched in front of them asking for a bit of cash; they also played drums, built guitars, wrote poetry, and told stories of their adventures. Over the course of the summer, I saw reunions of old hitchhiking friends, the formation of new bands, and all the shifts in human companionship that define our lives.
There’s nothing quite like that this year. And I won’t hesitate to blame this on the June 1 panhandling ordinance; while there are still some traveler kids lounging on benches, there just isn’t the same exchange of creativity, camaraderie, and, yes, money that there used to be. But there’s still a bit of music: the pianos recently installed by Marc Moen and Mark Ginsberg are rarely left silent.
Oddly enough, these two men (or, more accurately, their companies) are members of the Downtown Association, which lobbied heavily for the passage of the panhandling ban. The Downtown Association and Iowa City city councilors believe that panhandlers make pedestrians uncomfortable and that they make the Ped Mall a less enjoyable place to wander and, more importantly, shop.
Street musicians, however, note that the ordinance sees little difference between their practices and straight-up asking for money: banjo player Jon Eric told The Daily Iowan last month that he has seen police ask other players to pack up their instruments. He, and others, have expressed concern that the panhandling ordinance will do exactly what it is intended to do: run out those who play music for both pleasure and pay in favor of those deemed more socially acceptable.
One such band, the Cirque Stupendo, was hired by the Downtown Association to play an impromptu concert on July 10. Band member Alena Green recounted that the entire feel of the concert was one of seeming disorganization, and the group had a lot of audience participation — in short, it was the kind of show one might expect from traveling buskers. Instead of being funded by the compassion of strangers, however, they were on the payroll of a corporate union. At the same time, Ped Mall wanderers can get the same feeling of donating to the needy by depositing their coins in eight infamously purple “donation meters,” which, according to the DI, have each drawn in approximately $1 a day.
The panhandling ordinance is not directed at eliminating poverty. It is a beautification ordinance, dedicated to reducing the visibility of homelessness and need in an effort to make downtown a more enjoyable place to be. The panhandling ordinance may have cleared the sidewalks, but it also destroyed a masterpiece of organic self-organizing. Those meters, as the June 6 graffito said, will not sing you a song. The pianos and sponsored bands needn’t replace those truly impromptu jam sessions that happen to have a mug for donations. Nor can it: the desire for street music without street musicians, and donation jars without a human face, strikes me as irredeemably soulless. I’d prefer to meet people from all corners of humanity, whether or not they could use an extra buck.