Column: Unauthorized and inappropriate

By Anthony Russo

I have a lot of free time on my hands, as I am currently recovering from a paralyzing instance of Guillain-Barre Syndrome (I’ll explain in my first Fall column). All the lying around in bed has forced me to be deluged with every single news story. The oil spill, midterm elections, the economy: all potential topics of discussion for this summer edition of the IC.

I’ve been watching all of the cable news outlets, putting my critical thinking skills to the test. Strangely enough, I found myself in agreement with Rachael Maddow when she appeared on Jay Leno’s Tonight Show. My thoughts on the oil spill were similar to hers.

Why do we allow these companies to drill when the government has no way of overriding them in the event of a mishap? Bush has been out of office for quite some time. Obama’s job is to manage our executive branch, so unfortunately, a failure of the Mineral Management Service should reflect poorly on him. Both Republicans and Democrats have failed to produce a substantial long-term energy plan reflecting the true cost of gasoline, and have likely been negligent in what they allow oil companies to get away with. Ignorance is not an excuse. I was shocked when Rachel basically took the words right out of my mouth.

Anyway, I don’t want that scary moment to overtake my column. As Forrest Gump once said, “That’s all I’ve got to say about that.” I instead want to focus on something that has been bothering me for a while, something so heinous and vile that it eats away at my being. That’s right; I know it’s been bothering you too. Why do so many politicians think that they can use an artist’s or band’s songs without permission?

Perhaps most notably, Ronald Reagan got in trouble when he used “Born in the USA” by Bruce Springsteen back in 1984. Recently, this “party foul” has continued nonstop:

Don Henley of the Eagles recently won a lawsuit against senatorial candidate Chuck DeVore in California for DeVore’s adaptations of “All She Wants to Do is Dance” (“All She Wants to Do is Tax”) and “The Boys of Summer” (“Hope of November”) used in YouTube ads. Who does he think he is, Weird Al?

Another Eagles member, Joe Walsh, is a victim of this crime. From Aceshowbiz.com: “Earlier this year, the rocker’s lawyer sent a cease and desist letter to Illinois Republican Joe Walsh after learning the congressional candidate is using the more famous Walsh’s song ‘Walk Away’ at campaign rallies and public appearances without permission. Like DeVore, the less-famous Walsh had changed the song lyrics to suit his political message.”

In addition, Kentucky senatorial candidate Rand Paul has been using some songs from Rush, including “Tom Sawyer” and “Spirit of Radio,” and Florida Governor Charlie Crist has been using music from the Talking Heads in his Senate campaign, each prompting a lawsuit. All of this comes after the settling of Browne vs. McCain, which Jackson Browne won against John McCain for his use of “Running on Empty” during his presidential campaign in 2008, and a pledge by the Republican National Party not to use copyrighted works.

The problem, however, is that each of the above-listed offenders is a Republican. One would think that, as people promoting free markets (especially Rand Paul,) they would understand the concept of intellectual property rights. In most of the instances that I read about, the artist has claimed that they aren’t playing politics; they are just protecting their property. I couldn’t agree more; although I would go further to say that some of these candidates are totally oblivious to the meanings of the songs they use or the views of the artists who wrote them.

What Ronald Reagan failed to realize back in ‘84 was that “Born in the USA” is actually a song about the troubles of soldiers returning from Vietnam, not a chest-thumping anthem of patriotism. From the mouth of Bruce himself: “Down in the shadow of the penitentiary / Out by the gas fires of the refinery / I’m ten years down the road / Nowhere to run, ain’t got nowhere to go.”

I don’t think it would be too much of a stretch to say that very few recording artists vote Republican, with the exception of Country artists, perhaps.Strangely, many articles I’ve read note that the Canadian Power Trio (aka Rush) lean toward libertarians like Rand Paul. I guess I’ll have to listen to their lyrics more closely.

I concede that music and politics go hand-in-hand, but usually music criticizes actions of our government, and is a little more clever than “All She Wants to Do is Tax.” Protest songs spring to mind. I’ll admit that I don’t know the meaning of many of the songs I enjoy listening to, but if I were going to use a song to publically represent me I’d probably do two things: First, get permission to do so, and second, figure out exactly what themes I’m promoting by playing that song. Come on guys, the jig is up. I would offer the same advice given by Dr. Mike Dowd about cheating on tests: Just don’t do it.

The saddest part of all this is perhaps the most inevitable. I can picture myself driving with my windows down and sunroof open, when “Tom Sawyer” comes on the radio. Instead of rocking out to Neil Peart’s and Geddy Lee’s brilliance, I’ll be thinking about Rand Paul, midterm elections, and (for whatever reason) John Boehner’s incredible tan.

—Anthony Russo is a U. Toledo senior majoring in economics

Read more here: http://www.independentcollegian.com/forum/unauthorized-and-inappropriate-1.2279409
Copyright 2026 The Independent Collegian