CAS to become three colleges

By Randiah Green

The School of 21st Century Teaching and Learning, School of the Study of the Human Condition and the School of Earth and Space Exploration could be the future of the University of Toledo if the restructuring plan proposed by the Committee on Strategic Organizations gets implemented at the university.

In June, UT President Lloyd Jacobs charged the CSO with proposing “an organizational structure appropriate for the 21st Century and beyond and enable [UT] to realize [the] Strategic Plan” and doing “no harm to degree programs which are located within schools creating opportunities for creativity and collaboration.”

The committee has now produced the final draft of their proposed restructuring plan for the university as a whole in the form of a Power Point presentation.

The College of Arts and Sciences may be split into three colleges under the committee’s restructuring plan.

The plan proposes to separate the CAS into the College of Science and Sustainability, the College for the Study of the Human Condition and the College of Visual and Performing Arts.

These colleges will then be further broken down into several separate schools including the School of Earth and Space Exploration, the School of Transformative and Sustainable Solutions, the School of Performing Arts, and the School of Human and Social Dynamics.

Though the CAS will be split into three separate colleges, under the restructuring plan, the colleges will still be in a cluster called “Arts and Sciences” that will be headed by an Executive Dean.

“The existing Deans rotate into the position of Executive Dean as stewards, coordinators, and advocates for the colleges within their clusters,” said Jamie Barlowe, professor and chair of women’s and gender studies, who sits on the committee.

Debra Davis, professor and chair of art who also sits on the CSO, said the purpose of an Executive Dean is to oversee and assist faculty with collaborative projects.

“It’s a conceptual thing,” she said. “This person would be set aside from one of those already existing deans that would look at specific projects and be there as a facilitator so it doesn’t become so cumbersome of an idea for [the faculty] to work on.”

There will also be a Senior Executive Dean who, according to Barlowe, will coordinate communication and interaction among the Executive Deans and College Deans.

The plan also groups the College of Health Science and Human Services, the College of Medicine, College of Nursing and the College of Pharmacy under a group called Global Health, Wellness and Community with an Executive Dean.

This grouping breaks the College of Health Science and Human Services into six separate schools including the School of Kinesiology, School of Psychology Legal Specialties and Counselor Education, and the School of Criminal Justice and Social Work.

The last grouping of colleges under the restructuring plan will be called Professional and Translational Engagement with an Executive Dean.

This grouping includes the College of Business Innovation, Entrepreneurship and Leadership, the Judith Herb College of Educator Development Leadership and Policy, the College of Law, and the College of Engineering.

This calls for the Judith Herb College of Educator Development, Leadership and Policy to be broken down into three schools; the School of Educational Transformation and Leadership, the School of Measurement and Assessment, and the School of 21st Century Teaching and Learning.

Barlowe said the new structure is intended to enhance the work already being done within the colleges.

“The proposed reorganization of the existing structure was intended to enhance the students’ experiences, providing them with even more opportunities for critical thinking and interdisciplinary problem solving and therefore more job opportunities,” she said.

Barlowe said changing the structure of the university is only an effort to address and solve “the problems of the 21st Century.”

“I think we have to keep very abreast of changes that are occurring in the changing world,” said Interim Dean of the CAS Nina McClelland. “We have to stay on the tip of the arrow in terms of leadership in the 21st century. What’s best for students right now is probably not what’s been in the classroom in the past 20 years.”

Restructuring UT this way, according to Davis, is a way of “extending the dialogue” and encouraging more interdisciplinary, multidisciplinary and collaborative efforts and studies.

“It’s a grouping of different studies in order to create a collaborative and creative program in those areas,” she said. “This is for people that would be working together to make a stronger connection in different areas together that maybe weren’t working together before in an effort to extend things beyond one department. All the programs and the degree programs are exactly as they are, though. Nothing changes.”

Some faculty members find the plan for restructuring insulting.

Chair of the Arts and Science Council and associate professor of French Linda Rouillard, said the plan has an underlying assumption that faculty are not creative and integrative enough in their teaching already.

“The assumption is that we are not being creative enough, but one needs only to look at the cross listing classes we have and the kind of collaborations we have,” she said. “We could do more, but the only thing we need to do that is compensation for the faulty that do these things. When faculty members team-teach, one of the faculty members is not being paid for that course. Not only are faculty members team-teaching across disciplines, but they’re not being paid for it.”

Davis said there is nothing wrong with the current interdisciplinary and multidisciplinary efforts of faculty; this is just a way to “extend the dialogue.”

“There is nothing wrong with the current structure of colleges, nor are faculty doing anything wrong,” Barlowe said. “However, like many universities and colleges across the country which are restructuring, the University of Toledo must remain open to new ways of thinking and new modes of delivery for courses, as well as provide more opportunities for integrative student learning and interdisciplinary research and more opportunities for faculty collaboration, research and teaching.”

Despite the dedication to enhancing creative teaching and interdisciplinary studies put forth by the CSO, some who do not sit on the committee do not agree with the restructuring methods.

“They make up these terms and forget that these terms have no meaning,” said David Nemeth, professor of geography. “There’s no plan there; nothing that has been proven that works. They’re just changing the names. They change the names to keep up with the fads.”

Nemeth said dismantling the colleges is like “Humpty Dumpty.”

“You can’t put it together again if it turns out to be a bad idea,” he said. “We used to say ‘see you at the library’ but now we say ‘see you at the game.’ What happened to the academic focus of the university? What’s in the library now? They’re taking all the books out; they’ve destroyed it. They’re going to do the same thing they did to the library.”

Rouillard said the names of the newly proposed colleges are confusing.

“We have listed a school for earth and space exploration; is that physics? Are we about to go into the astronaut training program,” she said. “There’s the college for the study of the human condition. If you’re going to study the human condition, I want to see a school that studies the way we staff our university, the way we exploit faculty and the way we do this on the backs of students who pay top dollar for tuition when [faculty members] are not being paid top dollar.”

Lawrence Anderson Huang, professor and chair of astronomy, said the committee seemed to put too much focus on restructuring the CAS.

“For a committee that was extensibly charged with drafting a strategic reorganization of the university, they sure spent a lot of effort on the College of Arts and Sciences and nothing anywhere else,” he said.

Though McClelland said she thinks restructuring the university to provide better opportunities for students is the right thing to do, when it comes to splitting the CAS, McClelland said it should be left as it is.

”I hope we don’t do that,” she said. “I think we’re doing wonderful things. Do I think we’re doing everything we can? No, but I don’t think there’s anything we can achieve by splitting the college. We have had the arts and sciences together historically. I think we can have more multi disciplinary studies and interdisciplinary studies, but I think we can do that without splitting the college.”

Anderson Huang said one of the most problematic things about the plan is the way it’s presented.

“It’s just a Power Point presentation,” he said. “There’s no research indicated. There’s no indication that they have looked at other institutions and what other institutions have experienced with this. If we’re going to change the university, we should do it in a very organized way. After all, we’re changing the institution. I just think that this is really quite ‘Mickey Mouse.’”

Davis said the plan only offers suggested possibilities which will not change any degree programs.

The ideas in the final draft of the proposed plan came from a number of outside input including Jacobs’ address on “the relevant university,” according to Davis.

“We looked at the higher learning commission, the strategic plan, the relevant university document, proposals from the past from different departments and variations of different kinds of schools,” she said. “There were lots of ideas from the members on the committee and their experiences with other faculty as well.”

According to Davis, the plan has been sent to Jacobs who is reviewing it now.

There has been no student input on the proposed restructuring plan yet, but Barlowe said student input will be sought out in the fall when they return to the campus.

“The new structure is a proposal, and input will be sought from all university stakeholders,” she said.

Some faculty, however, are already giving their input and have their own ideas for restructuring the university.

According to Lawrence Anderson Huang, some department chairs are constructing their own alternative restructuring proposal along with the Arts and Science Council drafting a response to the Committee on Strategic Organization’s plan.

Anderson Huang said there “must be a better way to improve the institution.”

“At first there would be a great deal of confusion,” he said. “We still would be teaching the same courses and so on, but the confusion of faculty not knowing where they are, the confusion of students not really knowing where their new home is and finding advisors assuming that everything is going to be shifted around, I just don’t think it is worth it. That’s not worth any outcome.”

“You see it all throughout this document, ‘do no harm,’” Nemeth said. “But how can you do no harm when you’re breaking and tearing things apart?”

Read more here: http://www.independentcollegian.com/news/cas-to-become-three-colleges-1.2279395
Copyright 2026 The Independent Collegian