Smoke and mirrors: Students debate new smoking policies

By Madison Dennis

The neon yellow-green papers taped to the doors of the residence halls call attention to the change taking place across Kansas. These papers warn students in the residence halls of the new Clean Air Act, which came into effect July 1.

The act states that not only is smoking prohibited in most buildings, restaurants and bars, but smokers must stand at least 10 feet away from doorways, open windows or air intakes of buildings where smoking is prohibited.

Evidence of this new act is seen as several ashtrays across campus have been moved outside these prohibited areas.

“I kind of like it,” said Britney Klotz, senior in nursing. “It’s probably kind of annoying for people who smoke, but it’s annoying for a lot of people to walk through smoke to get to their classes.”

Wichita has delayed the implementation of this act with a pending lawsuit from several businessmen who say that the law would kill their business. Only businesses within Wichita city limits are subject to this delay.

“The law is hypocritical,” said Jared Johnson, a junior in business. “The state made their own casinos exempt from the law. People should be able to decide on their own whether or not they want to go into a place because of the smoke.”

Johnson has smoked for one year, and acknowledges the dangers of his habit.

“But that’s my decision. It isn’t the government’s business.”

Johnson says that while the 10-foot rule is not too inconvenient, his problem with the law has nothing to do with whether or not he gets rained on when he is having a cigarette.

“It isn’t that it bothers me to get wet when I want a smoke, it’s that the government is telling me where I have to stand when I want to exercise my rights,” he said.

However, other students think that the law is helping to protect people rather than take away their rights.

“There’s a lot less second-hand smoke to go through when you are walking through the doors,” said Klotz. “And if this law can get some people to quit, then that is definitely a good thing.”

The act states that cities that have less strict smoking ordinances than the state law will be required to adopt the state law. Cities that have provisions stricter than the state law may maintain those provisions. Businesses are also now required to post signs stating that smoking is prohibited by state law. The signs are available for free via download, or business may request that they be mailed the signs.

“I don’t think this is really like a taking-your-rights-away thing,” said Klotz. “It’s more like, you can’t drive drunk because you could hurt someone, and you can’t smoke where other people are around because smoking is harmful.”

The 10-foot radius rule means that smoking on the sidewalks of Broadway would prove difficult, because of the proximity of so many doorways. But however inconvenient it may be, Johnson says smokers will still smoke.

“Nobody I know is going to quit just because they have to walk a little farther away to smoke,” said Johnson. “I don’t feel like this law has any real benefits for citizens, smoking or non-smoking.”

On the other hand, Klotz says the act encourages a healthier society.

“The less smoking can be a normal part of life, the better,” said Klotz.

Read more here: http://media.www.psucollegio.com/media/storage/paper437/news/2010/07/08/FrontPage/Smoke.And.Mirrors-3922978.shtml
Copyright 2026 Collegio