Siblings unite in State College this summer

By Jake Kaplan

Playing sports at different colleges that spanned different seasons, Justin and Whitney Bencsko hadn’t seen much of each other the last couple of years.

Oddly enough, that changed for the better when Justin was selected by the Pittsburgh Pirates in the 20th-round on the second day of the Major League Baseball Amateur Draft on June 8.

Whitney, the junior co-captain of the Penn State’s women’s gymnastics team, got a phone call from her brother later that night. By that time, however, Whitney had already heard the news — her brother would be spending the summer in State College.

“He was like ‘Hey Whit, you know how you said you wanted to see me more this summer?’ ” Whitney recalled of her conversation with Justin the night of June 8.

Justin, who is three years older than Whitney, had been assigned to play for the Pirates’ short-season Class A affiliate, the State College Spikes. After four years of collegiate baseball at Villanova, Justin’s professional baseball career was going to get its start in the same town his sister Whitney was spending her summer, rehabbing her torn posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) and preparing for the upcoming gymnastics season.

“Honestly, it was awesome when we found out that’s where Justin would be,” Paula Bencsko, Justin and Whitney’s mother, said. “There was a one in a million chance that he would end up playing baseball in the same town in that same area as Whitney. It’s pretty unbelievable if you ask me.”

Paula said before the draft, Justin told his mother that if he was drafted by the Pirates he would probably play in State College. But not knowing where he would go in the draft or if he would get selected at all for that matter, the probability of that seemed slim.

“We just sort of laughed about like what are the chances of that ever happening and then low and behold it did,” Paula said. “So it was like the perfect situation actually.”

Justin and Whitney, natives of Pompton Plains, N.J., and graduates of Pequannock High School, had been relegated to only seeing each other on holiday breaks from school since Whitney came to Happy Valley in the fall of 2008. Even during the summer they didn’t see much of each other because Justin would always play summer baseball.

There is no doubt this summer is different.

Since Justin arrived, Whitney has tried to catch as many of the Spikes’ 11 home games as possible. Justin has started in 10 of those 11 games at Medlar Field at Lubrano Park and has started all eight road games. He is tied for first on the Spikes with six stolen bases thus far.

“I think the first game was the coolest because we walked in and it was like ‘Oh, wow. He’s actually down there. He’s actually playing,’ ” Whitney said. “It’s crazy. You don’t think like ‘My brother is actually going to be down there.’ And it’s so convenient, so easy.”

When Whitney was younger, she enjoyed going to her brother’s little league games, especially when Justin’s Little League All-Star Team — which was coached by their father Doug — won the New Jersey state championship and traveled to Bristol, Conn. to play for a spot in the Little League World Series. Justin’s team eventually lost to the team from the Bronx, led by Danny Almonte, and failed to qualify, but Whitney along with other girls who had brothers on the team loved going to the games.

Justin would do his best to return the favor and go to Whitney’s gymnastics meets, but it was tough because he was busy with baseball, not to mention soccer and basketball, sports he played through high school.

“Gymnastics is tough because you go to those meets and you’re there for five hours and you watch them do one event,” said Justin, the only male of four Bencsko children. “So I made it some that I could.”

However, Justin, has yet to make it to Rec Hall to see his sister compete for the Nittany Lions. The one time he was ever in State College before this summer was last fall, when he witnessed Penn State’s 21-10 loss to Iowa at Beaver Stadium. He hopes to make it to one of his sister’s meets this coming winter, during the baseball offseason.

“The kids are all close,” Paula said. “Their close at times and then their situations take them apart like they were at different schools, each of them very busy. They’d keep in contact, but this is a nice little bonding experience.”

Read more here: http://www.collegian.psu.edu/archive/2010/07/08/siblings_unite_in_state_colleg.aspx
Copyright 2026 Daily Collegian