Column: Drug testing unemployed would be impractical

By Warren Hale

Nobody wants unemployed junkies cashing taxpayer’s checks in-between nodding off and shooting-up. However, the proposed legislation from republican Sen. Orrin Hatch of Utah to drug test all who apply for unemployment benefits or welfare would be an ineffective waste of money. And here’s why:
According to Sen. Hatch, the test would be paid for with money saved by not paying benefits. “Any monies left over would go to help the states with the drug testing and so forth, and if there’s any surplus it goes to pay off the deficit,” he said. He added, “the goal would be to get users into treatment.” The aim is to identify and help people in need of drug treatment all the while reducing state’s costs.

This sounds like a great idea! However, the main problems with drug testing are the biased and easily manipulated results. This would merely squander taxpayer’s money as opposed to saving it.

The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services puts, “conservative estimates for standard workplace urine tests from $25 to $75 per test.” And, according to Exotic G & G Smokeshop, drug testing kits for urine analysis range from $35 to $45 per kit.

I know people who have passed piss tests, hair tests, etc. Hell, I have a friend who wore a prosthetic penis with a fake urine bag to work every day for years in case he popped a random. Instead of pin-pointing/helping unemployed drug users to seek treatment, unemployed drug users would use their monies to hoodwink the results.

The second problem with Hatch’s plan is drug testing is ineffective. Harold Pollack, the Helen Ross Professor of Social Service Administration at the University of Chicago, has studied drug testing those on public assistance closely “The likely consequence is to stretch states’ already overburdened screening, assessment, and referral systems with large numbers of casual marijuana users,” he said. “In part, this pattern reflects a technological quirk: Urine tests more readily detect marijuana than they can detect other intoxicating substances. In part this pattern reflects the basic epidemiology of illicit drug use.” In other words, a wide drug testing net catches mostly stoner fish.

The proposed legislation has sparked criticism from Hatch’s compatriots as well. According to democratic Sen. Barbara Mikulski Maryland, “I think it’s a punitive attitude. Who’s going to pay for the test? What’s the point of the test? You know, why do you want to drug test people who have lost their job?”

In a perfect world, everyone would have a job and drugs would be legal–-made available to adults like alcohol and tobacco. However, some drugs are legal and some drugs are not. Were Sen. Hatch’s proposal to include tobacco, OxyContin and alcohol, it would almost seem just. Of course, a product would just come out to mask them as well.

Regardless of your stance on unemployment benefits, this proposal would be a waste of money for everyone except head shops. Unless Utah has a particular hard-on against pot smokers this proposal should go up in smoke.

Read more here: http://www.dailynebraskan.com/hale-drug-testing-unemployed-would-be-impractical-1.2278485
Copyright 2026 Daily Nebraskan