In 2006, The Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) took on Kellogg’s for advertising sugary cereal to children. Also in 2006, the CSPI took on KFC for using partially hydrogenated oil. And just recently, the CSPI took on McDonald’s for using toys to promote Happy Meals.
According to the CSPI’s website, McDonald’s is violating various state consumer protection laws by unfairly and deceptively marketing Happy Meals to children. They claim that, based on scientific research, children can not understand or resist the marketing that McDonald’s bombards them with.
I am inclined to agree with some aspect of the CSPI’s allegations. Of course children don’t have the cognitive abilities to realize McDonald’s is using the toys to entice them into screaming for a Happy Meal until their lungs explode.
But for that matter, are most adults able to comprehend the same tactic for ourselves? Why is it that most commercials feature attractive models selling various products? Because it works. At least the children get a toy with the Happy Meal. I’ve never gotten a sexy model with any of the cars or jeans that I have bought.
The main issue for the CSPI in this lawsuit is the promotion of unhealthy food. They don’t want children eating cheeseburgers, fries and a soda. This argument makes a lot more sense, as this Happy Meal combination has about 640 calories, or half of what a child of 4 to 8 years of age should be eating.
However, McDonald’s has added healthier options to the Happy Meal, including Chicken McNuggets, Apple Dippers and low-fat milk. These options bring the count down to about 430 calories. This may not be the ideal healthy meal for a child, but who stops at McDonald’s expecting to eat healthy food?
The CSPI did get one important thing right. We need to be feeding our children, and ourselves, healthier meals. But lawsuits keeping toys out of Happy Meals is not the way to do it. Taking personal responsibility for ourselves and our children is the correct way.
Children are not driving themselves to McDonald’s in search of a Happy Meal. Their parents are. These same parents are usually buying unhealthy meals for themselves as well.
The CSPI should be trying to influence the parents rather than throwing frivolous lawsuits at these corporations. They should teach parents where the healthiest meals are. The best solution to this problem is having parents vote with their purchase.
As long as there is a substantial market for these unhealthy kid’s meals, McDonald’s and other similar restaurants will continue to find a way to market them to children. We have to be adult enough to say no to a screaming child. We have to be responsible enough to either cook or buy them, and ourselves, meals that will be nutritious without relying on an organization to force us into submission.