Column: The modern value of an old idea – Why do we go to college?

By Alex McElroy

Graduation is over. Your parents have returned to hometowns – in some cases dragging you with them. And the euphoria of having graduated, if you ever felt it, has dissolved.

Now what? Do you job-hunt (not to be confused with the anachronistic “job-find”)? Drink recreationally? Traverse Europe?

Whichever you choose, be prepared to employ your highly developed BSing ability (the skill you bragged about weekly at parties). Though now you won’t be wasting your talent on bacc-core English essays, but on yourself, as soon you’ll face a litany of vague, existential questions that, likely, will remain unanswered.

I’m referring to the “whys” and the “whats” that a college diploma invokes. What, exactly, has one done after four to eight years of schooling? Why did one even go to college? Sure, the drinking was fun, and Halloween met all my Dionysian expectations, but what have I really done?

The question is uncannily pertinent for our class, and unlikely to dissolve like that short-lived euphoria of graduating.

For most of us, the malignant emotion growing rapidly in our stomachs is fear. Think of all the cool stuff we could’ve bought had we not gone to college.

Loan companies don’t care that we’ve matured; that we’re better equipped for roundtable discussions and beer pong tournaments. They want money. And as we don the ball caps and crested polo shirts of the service industry, we’re forced to wonder, again, “Why?”

In a recent New Yorker article, Rebecca Mead questioned the value of a college degree. For nascent statisticians and accountants, the future is only somewhat dim. Roughly 50 percent of graduates in both fields have already been offered jobs, and their starting salaries hover around the $40,000 to $50,000 range.

Then there are the rest of us. Graduates who are perfect candidates for an argument put forward by Richard K. Vedder, a professor at Ohio State University.

In a New York Times article, Vedder advocates for a stronger high school system that prepares youths for the job market, rather than preparing them for college.

The article makes note that “eight out of the ten job categories that will add the most employees during the next decade . . . can be performed without a college degree.”

And Vedder, founder of the Center for College Affordability and Productivity, believes we should rethink our assumptions about bachelor’s degrees and the value of college, in general.

And thus we return to us, the graduates and, like me, semi-graduates finishing a degree over the summer. Why did we do it? Personally, I did it because it was what one did after high school. Because I harbored romantic delusions of grandeur, of a second mortgage and 1.7 kids. Because I was expected to.

Looking back, I regret nothing about my decision. But for those of us who assumed our diplomas would act like tickets to a ball game, where the usher to life tears our stub and leads us to a specified seat, we’re quickly learning that two of every ticket was made and our seats are already occupied.

The allure of a bachelor’s degree has disappeared.

But why was that allure there in the first place? Is it due to the potential a degree offers? Or is it that college provides what the real world refuses to, an extension of adolescence?

We see our parents – people who’ve succumbed to the ennui and monotony of daily existence – and it incites an inexplicable, yet crippling, fear of reality. Is that it?

If only it were that simple. The allure is entangled with our own Americanness; with an inherently human desire to succeed. A desire to ascertain an identity we don’t fully understand, but nevertheless struggle to adopt.

Somewhere along the line, college became the logical stepping stone on the path to success. Whether or not it’s required, we college students assume that it is.

Because of that, we gladly put ourselves into debt. It’s an irrational chase for stardom, or at least quotidian middle-class-dom, and its implicit irrationality remains peripheral.

Vedder’s argument is practically flawless. In relation to the job market and the passionless attitude toward education that many students harbor, the logical choice would be to avoid college altogether and snatch up that service position four years early.

What Vedder doesn’t account for, however, is that logic and rationality bother few students once they leave their philosophy classes. For most, the decision to attend college is visceral. The same goes for their parents.

At 18 years old, we assume college is the logical step to success, and most parents wholly agree. Few parents would rather see their children join the military or work at Burger King than enroll in classes.

At 18, we fall in love with the idea college presents, the idea that four years of study is necessary to engage with the world properly – whether or not that’s true, it strongly helps, at the very least. And then there are our loved ones, who see us as walking potential, as the opportunity to transcend the social class we were born into. Essentially, to fulfill the American Dream.

And that’s why Vedder’s vision cannot develop. Unless the grandiose idea of college shifts, university attendance will remain stable, if not increase.

Currently, our attendance at Oregon State is an emotion, a commitment to an abstraction: success. It’s a commitment I refuse to break, because I want what we all do: a better life, a happy life, a life I will not regret. And, like everyone else, when faced with an argument like Vedder’s, I will shun the rational for the visceral and work for a degree that I might never use.

The question of “What will I do with my degree?” is unapproachable. I don’t care if the answer is nothing, I want it.

And as for “Why?” my response is simple: because.

– Alex McElroy is an Oregon State U. senior in English.

Read more here: http://media.barometer.orst.edu/media/storage/paper854/news/2010/07/07/Forum/The-Modern.Value.Of.An.Old.Idea.Why.Do.We.Go.To.College-3922881.shtml
Copyright 2026