Thursday marks the beginning of the 2010-11 fiscal year and with three different budget proposals before the California Legislature and a $19.1 billion budget gap to close, state lawmakers and Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger are far from signing a budget bill into law.
The three different budget plans – one crafted by Schwarzenegger, a second by state Senate Democrats and a third by state Assembly Democrats – all strive to preserve the state’s higher education institutions, though they differ in their treatment of issues including social services and taxes. Although the budget was due Wednesday, lawmakers failed to come to a consensus. If not remedied, this will leave many state programs unfunded and state contractors unpaid.
The budget proposals completely spare higher education from further budget cuts by agreeing to increase funding to the U. California and the California State U. to compensate for last year’s reductions. Approximately $610 million – $305 million to each institution – will be allocated to UC and CSU budgets. The UC and the CSU will also receive $51.3 million and $60.1 million respectively for enrollment growth.
The proposals will also shelter the Cal Grant financial aid program by rescinding Schwarzenegger’s suspension of competitive Cal Grant awards in his January revised budget and returning $45 million to the program.
A two-house budget conference committee consisting of five state senators and five assembly members has been working for the past several weeks in an attempt to reconcile the three proposals.
“We can never tell how long this process will take,” said Sen. Loni Hancock, D-Oakland. “Right now in the Senate we have a budget that we think is as good as it gets given the political and financial reality today. Whether or not the governor will agree, we don’t know.”
A two-thirds vote in both houses is required to sign the budget bill into law, causing gridlock in the budget process, Hancock said. Democrats will be unable to single-handedly approve their spending plans because the Legislature’s Republican minority has sufficient votes to block the bill’s passage.
“What the rule means is that a small number of legislators can hold up the budget and demand concessions that have nothing do with the budget,” she said. “They can essentially hold the state of California hostage.”
This rule is the reason California has a persistent budget deficit, as it makes it easier for the state to spend money than to pay it back, said John Ellwood, professor of public policy at UC Berkeley and a member of the board of directors of the California Budget Project.
Without a budget for the upcoming fiscal year, the state cannot pay different groups, including community colleges, local governments and businesses providing services for the state after July 1.
“Small businesses that provide services to the state after the budget deadline suffer until the Legislature does its job and passes a budget,” said Garin Casaleggio, spokesperson for the state controller’s office.
Other areas of state spending – including social services, health care and the state’s prison system – receive varied support from the three proposals.
Schwarzenegger’s budget completely eliminates the state’s welfare-to-work program, CalWORKs, providing the state with a net savings of $1.2 billion for the upcoming fiscal year. Both assembly and senate proposals reject this plan, choosing to maintain funding for the program.
Schwarzenegger’s plan also outlines cuts to local mental health care services, shifting $602 million in funds to non-mental health purposes. The assembly and senate plans reject this cut.
The budget proposals reduce funding to state prisons, including an $811 million reduction in prison health care costs. All three plans expect to save an additional $244 million by shifting low-level prisoners from state prisons to county jails.