SEC fails with cowbell compromise

By Paul Katool

At the annual Southeastern Conference meetings, which took place at the beginning of the month in Destin, Fla., the powers that be in the SEC focused on the most important issue regarding the 2010 football season: a new cowbell policy for Mississippi State fans.

All sarcasm aside, the SEC approved a one-year trial compromise that more or less strikes the 1974 ban by the SEC on artificial noisemakers – including cowbells – at league football and basketball games.

The policy states that Bulldog fans are allowed to ring their cowbells at times when music can be played – during pre-game, halftime, between quarters, time-outs, after scores and during possession changes.

This sounds fine and dandy for Mississippi State fans, but during an average conference match up, SEC stadiums contain enough Evan Williams and Beam’s Eight Star to flood the Grand Canyon. And with Jim Bob or Bobby Joe liquored up, they won’t know a time-out from a touchdown.

So ring-a-ling-a-ling those cowbells will go.

This harks back to 2007 when replay official Doyle Jackson overturned Ole Miss wide receiver Shay Hodge’s long reception against Alabama, ending hopes of the Rebels making a comeback.

It’s against the rules, and common sense, to throw anything on the field during a football game, but that didn’t stop students from launching liquor bottles and even a single red high-heel onto the south end zone.

What should be drawn from this anecdote is obvious – sports fans, including preteens and grandfathers, soccer moms and frat stars are going to get rowdy and boisterous during athletic events, whether it is because of alcohol or pure adrenaline.

And I’m certain that among these rowdy fans, there will be a large number of cowbell-wielding Mississippi State faithful that will adhere to the new rules set in place. But there will also be quite a few who will get caught up in the moment and ring their cowbells at inappropriate times or blatantly ignore the new rules altogether.

So, what I really want to know is what these consequences are going to be if, or when, fans at Davis Wade Stadium break the rules.

Fines, penalties, a slap on the wrist?

Fines aren’t going to work – most fans aren’t going to care about how much SEC Commissioner Mike Slive is charging on the MSU credit card as long as it isn’t hurting the Bulldogs on the playing field.

And the penalties seem a little harsh. How can the SEC rationalize slapping the Bulldogs with a 15-yard penalty or technical foul – something that could truly affect the outcome of a game – because a bunch of nuts are ringing bells?

So really, in my book there are two options the SEC should have chosen from instead of their greyarea approach: ban the cowbells and get serious about screening for and confiscating the noisemakers; throw people out of games if they don’t comply.

Or just give up and let the fans ring their cowbells, because the last time I checked that 1974 ban never stopped cowbells from ringing during their games anyway.

Read more here: http://www.thedmonline.com/article/sec-fails-cowbell-compromise
Copyright 2026 Daily Mississippian