Innocence Clinic client may be sent back to prison on technicality

By Devon Thorsby

Released from prison after eight years behind bars with the help of the Michigan Innocence Clinic, Michigan resident Lucinda Swain may be forced to return to incarceration due to a technicality noted by the Michigan Court of Appeals.

Swain, now 49, was convicted in 2002 of sexually assaulting her teenage son, Ronnie, whose testimony alone put her behind bars. Shortly after Swain was sentenced, Ronnie took back his accusation and has since tried to clear her record of the conviction.

The Innocence Clinic took an interest in Swain’s case in spring last year after Swain wrote to the clinic asking for help, according to an April 14 article in The Michigan Daily.

The clinic determined that Swain was innocent and that her conviction should be overturned, ultimately deciding to move forward with the case.

In a new trial under Calhoun County Circuit Court Judge Conrad Sindt, the judge who oversaw Swain’s initial conviction, the Innocence Clinic presented the new evidence of Ronnie’s recanted statement as well as testimonies from others that the clinic says the defense failed to consider significant at the time of the initial conviction.

Those to newly testify were Tanya Winterburn, Ronnie’s bus driver during the alleged incident, and William Risk, a boy who lived in the same neighborhood as Swain and her son at the time.

With the new evidence, Sindt overturned the conviction and ordered Swain to be released from prison in August of 2009, according to a press release from the Innocence Clinic.

But 10 months after her release on June 8, the Michigan Court of Appeals stated that the new evidence in Swain’s case cannot be heard by a court because too much time has passed since her original conviction, the press release said.

With Swain’s return to prison a distinct possibility, the Innocence Clinic said in the press release that it now plans to appeal to the Michigan Supreme Court, with the argument that the Michigan Court of Appeals interpreted the Michigan Court Rules incorrectly and are unconstitutionally keeping innocent people from being released.

Sindt ruled on June 21 that Swain may remain free during the appeals for her case. She was previously in jeopardy of having her bail revoked and being forced to return to prison while the Innocence Clinic continued to work on her case.

The clinic stated that a Michigan Supreme Court decision could change the future for many across the state who are currently in the prison system despite their innocence.

“The clinic hopes that the Michigan Supreme Court will agree that innocence is the most important consideration, and that hypertechnical interpretation of court rules cannot function to keep in prison a person who is able to prove her innocence,” the press release said.

Read more here: http://www.michigandaily.com/content/innocence-clinic-client-may-be-sent-back-prison-based-technicality
Copyright 2026 Michigan Daily