Supreme Court nominee Elena Kagan is set to begin her confirmation hearing today amid debate over whether her lack of judicial experience will play a role in her questioning before the Senate Judiciary Committee.
While Kagan is hardly a household name, local opinions on how Kagan fits into the Supreme Court picture abound.
“I put faith in President Obama that he made the right choice [in Kagan],” said Dane Hudson, co-president of University Democrats. “And I have faith in Senate that she’ll be confirmed.”
Kagan, 50, has been seen by many to be a safe choice by the Obama Administration to replace outgoing Justice John Paul Stevens.
A graduate of Princeton, Oxford, and Harvard, Kagan has no experience as a judge, but she served as an aide to former Justice Thurgood Marshall in addition to representing a number of cases before the Supreme Court while serving as solicitor general to the Obama administration. Supporters of Kagan note that many justices have had no judicial experience before being nominated to the high court, notably former Chief Justices William Rehnquist and Earl Warren.
Though Kagan has worked with a variety of Democratic politicians, including former President Bill Clinton and Michael Dukakis, she has shown little partisan favoritism in her decisions.
In 1997, Kagan urged then-President Clinton to support a ban on late-term abortions.
During her time as president of Harvard Law School, Kagan also took a vocal stand against federal policy insisting that colleges denying access to military recruiters should be denied federal funding in response to the “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” policy.
Politicians from Iowa have heralded Kagan’s nomination with mixed reviews.
“A lifetime appointment requires a thorough vetting, and I expect Elena Kagan to receive fair, respectful, and deliberative consideration,” Sen. Charles Grassley, R-Iowa, said in a press release. “With no judicial experience, it becomes even more important that we ask thorough questions [of Kagan].”
Sen. Tom Harkin, D-Iowa, expressed high confidence in Kagan in a statement, saying “her stellar legal credentials have been recognized by liberal and conservative lawyers alike.”
Bruce Gronbeck, a UI professor emeritus with expertise in media and political studies, said Kagan’s confirmation will not be an easy process.
“The Republicans will send out attack dogs,” he said. “There are going to be points worked hard, particularly her lack of judicial experience,” but he thinks she will be confirmed.
UI law Professor Todd Pettys agreed.
“Republicans have vowed intensive questioning, but with 59 Democrats in Senate, there’s little doubt over [Kagan’s] future,” he said.
As for the potential changes her presence could have on the court, former UI political-science Associate Professor David Redlawsk noted Kagan’s position will be hard to determine.
“It’s highly unlikely, being that she’s replacing [John Paul] Stevens, the most liberal justice, that the court will go any further to the left,” he said.