Editorial: A Raw Deal

By Daily Californian Editorial Board

The Bain saga continues. The consulting company’s controversial involvement with UC Berkeley’s Operational Excellence (OE) initiative appears to be far from over. On the contary, recent developments indicate that the campus is planning to expand the firm’s mandate to include implementing the potential improvements that it identified. However, the cost of this renewed involvement with Bain is troublesome.

Bain is set to be compensated to the tune of $2.7 million to aid in executing the recommendations of the OE reports in two of the functional areas covered by the initiative. However, if Bain is able to actually come through and save $7.2 million in procurement costs for the university, it will receive a bonus payment of $1.8 million.

We do not have a problem with Bain or Operational Excellence, in principle. It is common practice for organizations facing financial challenges to hire expensive consultants in order to increase efficiency. Budget cuts have exposed just how necessary it is for UC Berkeley to reform its organizational structure. And considering that the initial Bain report found at least $100 million in potential savings, of which the administration says it is intent on taking advantage, hiring the firm may not have been a terrible idea.

What we do have a problem with is the cost of this latest move by the campus administration. Paying over $4 million in order to save $7 million leads us to ask if perhaps an open bidding process would have led to a better financial bargain for the school. And if Bain’s job is to reduce costs, why pay them a bonus for a successful job when their initial cost is already so high? A more incentive-based deal seems to make more sense. Let us base the consultants’ pay on a simple criteria: how well they save the campus money.

Spending a bit of money to save a lot of money is a concept that bears merit. But we’re growing nervous that the campus is spending so many resources on the OE process that it is forgetting the ultimate goal of the entire endeavor.

Read more here: http://www.dailycal.org/article/109728/a_raw_deal
Copyright 2026 Daily Californian