Recently there’s been a lot of chatter about the Gross National Debt of the United States and the government expenditures necessary to sustain the recovery of our economy. We’ve seen grotesque projections of where the level of our nation’s debt could be in the coming years, and subsequently it’s become a favored talking point of politicians, with deficit hawks seemingly coming out of the woodwork.
First off, I don’t want to be misunderstood on this topic. Debt is a burden and a nuisance, and potentially toxic to the economic livelihood of a nation. But debt is also not completely disadvantageous. It can have significant strategic benefits if used appropriately, similar to a student loan. Secondly, when talking about levels of national debt, nominal amounts — such as $10 billion — are not as useful of a metric as is the amount of debt as a percentage of that nation’s Gross Domestic Product. That being said, does our current spending entail certain doom for the country?
While it’s true that our level of national debt is close to reaching 100 percent of our GDP — roughly $14 trillion — this is not uncharted territory for the United States as many politicians and media pundits would have you believe. The highest our national debt has been, in modern history, was 120 percent of GDP. This was in 1945-46 under presidents Roosevelt and Truman, and was a response to the costs of World War II. After that peak, the next 35 years saw a general downward trend in the national debt, from 120% percent of GDP to 33 percent in 1980. It was with the Reagan administration that we entered a new period of upward trending national debt levels. Under President Reagan’s two terms we saw the nominal value of our national debt triple, and by 1990 our debt level was back up to 56 percent of GDP.
It continued to rise under George Bush, Sr., then declined under Clinton, and began to rise again under George Bush, Jr. The United States went from a debt level of 65 percent of GDP in 2007, to roughly 85 percent at the end of George W. Bush’s presidency a year later.
Barack Obama took office at the beginning of 2009, and the most current count put us at a debt level of 90 percent of GDP, with estimates of reaching just under 100 percent by the end of this year, and set to begin declining by 2013.
The reasons for these fluctuations in debt are numerous. Under Reagan, the most prominent reasons for his tripling of our national debt were his steep tax cuts on the national revenue side and increased spending on things like discretionary defense on the expenditure side. Under Bush, Sr. the rise can be explained by wars in the Middle East and the recession of 1991. Clinton’s decrease in debt can be attributed to dramatic increases in GDP and also to his balancing of the national budget and even running a surplus in one year.
The administration of Bush, Jr. saw the return of budget deficits with numerous tax cuts and increased spending on the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.
But the current spike in debt levels, seen under the end of George W. Bush’s term and the beginning of Barack Obama’s, is due to the massive monetary stimuli and corporate bailouts that were needed in 2008 and 2009 in order to keep our economy from falling into a severe depression.
It’s important to understand that while politically unpopular, these recent expenditures are necessary responses to macroeconomic cycles. And though combating the financial crisis with these one-time costs has temporarily increased the nominal value of our national debt, we shouldn’t let the issue become a political scapegoat for not tackling other pressing issues facing our country.
While balancing our budget is a very important task, attempting to do so too early could plunge a fragile economy back into turmoil. FDR made this mistake in 1937 while the economy was still recovering from the Great Depression; he attempted to balance the budget too early and sent the economy back into a recession. Like it or not, doing so now would run the risk of wasting the many billions we’ve already spent on stimulus.
While this recent criticism of our nation’s debt serves an important role in keeping an eye on the long-term fiscal health of our country, it’s also crucial to see things in the correct context; as perspective and context are friends of the wise.
The United States is one of the richest and most innovative countries ever to exist. We’ve never defaulted on our debt and there are many countries that far exceed our level of debt relative to GDP. The current budget deficits needed to support our recovering economy are only temporary. And while the current level of debt is high, The United States has seen deeper depths and prevailed.