Editorial: Are more police the answer to downtown violence?

By Daily Iowan Editorial Board

NO

Violence, much like excessive drinking, has been a problem in downtown Iowa City for quite some time — and the University of Iowa police say they’re looking to help deter it. At a whopping cost of at least $249,935 in annual salaries, seven additional officers were recruited as of June 1 to help patrol downtown on weekend nights.

However, the real question here is: Will adding seven new officers to the UI police force really be the most effective solution to this problem?

In discussing the matter with Iowa City police Sgt. Denise Brotherton, she expressed hope the new officers will help decrease levels of violence downtown by having more officers patrol the streets.

Though the reader may be inclined to immediately support this extra vigilance, the DI Editorial Board is split on this for two reasons.

I personally doubt whether — despite the departments’ good intentions in hiring additional officers — this is a proper solution for curbing violence, when the majority of the officers’ time and attention appear to be spent in the company of downtown establishments. It is easy to get called away writing underage drinking tickets to minors as opposed to vigilantly patrolling the Pedestrian Mall.

Brotherton said reaching the goal of decreased violence may take some time, because all new officers are required to go through extensive training. Any visible progress downtown will not be immediately noticeable.

Though their attempts to tone down the violence seem sincere enough, I question the timing in hiring these additional officers. Are they out in the most problematic areas patrolling for underage drinkers or for violent crimes?

— by Taylor Casey

YES

Earlier this summer, the University of Iowa police hired seven officers to staff a new patrol. This beat, which went into effect on June 1, circulates officers through the Pedestrian Mall on 10-hour shifts, Wednesday through Saturday. Once the clock strikes 7 p.m., the officers keep careful watch over downtown revelers.

I say, it’s about time. These officers — and this beat — are long overdue.

The UI police had already manned this patrol, through voluntary overtime, before it became an official part of the department’s schedule this month. That arrangement, however, had the effect of inducing large amounts of stress on the officers, said Charles Green, the assistant vice president for the UI police.

Talk of the new, after-hours beat has circulated since 2006, when a series of sexual assaults occurred near downtown. Even though that particular crime streak seems to have dissipated, it has since been supplanted by an increasingly violent drinking culture.

While I’m not often one to think increasing police oversight is always the best answer (exemplified by my strong stance against the recently implemented curfew), denying the necessity or practicality of this beat is naïve at best. The simple fact of the matter is that downtown violence is still a regular and unnecessary component of Iowa City nightlife. While opponents may be concerned with the $250,000 price tag, let us not forget that this patrol was already being manned. It’s not like we weren’t paying for this security.

Now, however, instead of paying officers to work overtime and stretching their workforce thin, there is a regular, fresh group of officers paid exclusively to keep downtown safe. And it’s already showing results, according to Assistant Vice President Charles Green, most significantly in the recent apprehension of a person suspected of sexually assaulting a 14-year-old girl.

This sounds like a pretty wise investment to me. Case closed.

— Zach Wahls

Read more here: http://www.dailyiowan.com/2010/06/22/Opinions/17618.html
Copyright 2026 The Daily Iowan