Down, but are they out?

By Al Buzzelli

Momentum was the only thing that swung for the Seminoles on Saturday.

It took all but one inning for the ’Noles to find themselves on both sides of the fence: up one minute, then down the next as it was their opponent—the upstart Horned Frogs from Texas Christian—who seized control of the game and their College World Series fate after routing FSU 8-1 in the opening series game.

The Seminoles will now take on the Florida Gators Monday, June 21, at 4:30 p.m. in an elimination game that will be televised by ESPN2.

Storming out of the gates strong against TCU’s Matt Purke, a second-team All-American and the nation’s leader in victories (15), FSU struck first when leadoff man Tyler Holt lined a single into left field for the game’s first hit. Holt would go on to score FSU’s lone run of the afternoon after a subsequent throwing error resulting from Sherman Johnson’s infield single. While Purke settled down after his first inning stint, it was the TCU bats that were just getting started.

The Horned Frogs strung together six hits in the top half of the first, including two doubles, as five of their first six batters reached base and also came around to score. A total of four different TCU players earned RBI hits in the inning.

Leftfielder Jason Coats smacked a two-run RBI double into left field, designated hitter Joe Weik went for an RBI single, shortstop Taylor Featherston drove a run home with a sacrifice fly and center fielder Aaron Shultz gave TCU a 5-1 lead with a run-scoring single.

The relentlessness shown at the plate by TCU hitters was matched by Purke on the mound, who was pitching in his team’s first-ever College World Series game.

The freshman standout retired seven-straight Seminoles from the first through the third innings and faced one batter over the minimum in the second and third innings. After allowing the first two Seminole batters of the game to reach base via singles, Purke held Florida State hitless in the second through fifth innings.

Removed after seven Series-defining innings, Purke allowed just one (unearned) run on only four hits while striking out seven, thus marking the 10th time this season he has pitched into or beyond the seventh inning.

“If you had told me that we were going to get four hits in 27 outs, and one run, I think I would have discussed it with you,” FSU head coach Mike Martin said. “You really got to take your hat off to TCU. They did a great job.

“That’s a ball game that you can analyze. From our side, we didn’t make an error. You might just say we got our butts whipped, plain and simple.”

Tagged with the loss, the Seminoles’ starting pitcher Sean Gilmartin was replaced by sophomore Hunter Scantling to begin the fourth inning after Gilmartin’s shortest outing of the year in 17 appearances (15 as a starter and two in relief). The ’Noles ace allowed six earned runs on eight hits while striking out one.

“They were just putting the bat on the ball,” Gilmartin said. “I don’t really know how many balls they hit hard in that first inning, but I also got behind the count. So that didn’t really help me out at all.

“It’s been what’s happening with me all year long pretty much. Get ahead in the count 0-2, 1-2, and then not finishing things off. Obviously, I have to get better at that.”

After the Horned Frogs upped their lead to 6-1 in the third inning before Gilmartin departed, Scantling was promptly greeted by a one-out home run off the bat of catcher Bryan Holaday (his 14th of the year), extending the lead to 7-1.

Purke, paired with relief pitcher Eric Marshall (who came in after the seventh), effectively shut down the Seminoles after FSU took an early first-inning lead. After the first, the Seminoles had their leadoff runner reach base only four times, advanced only two runners as far as third base and left seven runners on base.

“[Purke] used all three pitches well,” Holt said. “We didn’t help ourselves out a lot. I think it’s a totally different ball game if we’re more patient and better not swinging at that stuff that’s in the dirt. But that’s what happens when you have good stuff. It looks like it’s in the zone, then it comes out. That first inning killed us and then it kind of went on from there.”

Although the Seminoles struggled from the plate, their ability to keep themselves in the game defensively was something the ’Noles capitalized on. Five Seminole relief pitchers held the Horned Frogs to two runs and only five hits after the first inning. The foursome of Robert Benincasa, John Gast, Scott Sitz and Tyler Everett allowed a total of two hits, one run and six base runners in the fifth, sixth, seventh and eighth innings. Gast was able to pitch out of a bases loaded jam in the sixth inning by striking out TCU first baseman Matt Curry, as well.

TCU scored their final run of the 8-1 decision on an RBI single by Coats that scored right fielder Brance Rivera. Rivera had reached base on a single to lead off the inning off Everett.

“I wish there was something that I could say that would make any sense,” Martin said. “Certainly we’re disappointed, but this TCU club is very good. They whipped us today. And I got a few [losses] on my resume, so it’s nothing new.”

“Nothing new” indeed will again be the storyline for Martin’s squad as they gear up for a fifth matchup this season against the in-state Gators.

Florida State has taken three of the four matchups and will need to stretch that effort to four out of five if they want to stay in the hunt for a World Series title.

Read more here: http://www.fsunews.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20100621/FSVIEW02/100620014
Copyright 2026 FSView & Florida Flambeau