Utah death row inmate, Ronnie Lee Gardner, is set to be executed Friday by firing squad. Gardner will be the third person in the last 33 years to be executed in the United States by this method of execution. Although lethal injection is now Utah’s default method of execution, inmates sentenced before 2004 have the choice between firing squad and lethal injection.
Gardner made his decision when he said, “I would like the firing squad, please.”
Upon hearing about this issue, I initially wondered if death row inmates should be allowed to choose how they will die. Setting aside the death penalty argument in itself, inmates should be given the choice. Not just those convicted before 2004, but all inmates. If we are to strip away every right from them, even the right to live, we should allow them to choose how they will go.
Not only is our society deciding who should live or die, but we also decide exactly when and how they will die. I know that these felons come in the most horrific forms, but do we really need to strip every right that they have as fellow human beings? They are going to be executed one way or another; that choice should be left up to the individual prisoner, not suits in a courtroom.
Tomorrow Gardner will have paid the ultimate price for his crimes; there’s no reason not to let him die in the way of his choice. Utah and other states with the death penalty shouldn’t care how the debt to society is settled, only that it is paid in full.