Column: Finding fault with football

By Ian McPhail

Legitimate complaint 1: That buzzing sound isn’t a plague of locusts descending on South Africa. In many ways that would be preferable to the incessant hum of thousands of soccer fans blowing these horns constantly for both teams. These quasi-instruments drown out players and announcers, who lobbied FIFA to ban the vuvuzela. Unfortunately, the note-less horns are here to stay, prompting many fans to hit the mute button.

Legitimate complaint 2: It’s ironic the announcers complain about the vuvuzela volume, as they similarly waste the air in their lungs making useless noise. ESPN seems to have a rigorous selection process, where a commentator with only a vague understanding of vowels is chosen to explain that soccer is a game played with your feet, as the average American wonders what “offsides” means and why the game doesn’t end at 90 minutes.

Legitimate complaint 3: If the announcers could stop being condescending to Americans, they might have explained how players are punished for their various soccer crimes. The yellow card (caution) and the red card (send-off) seem based on the elementary school model of discipline, especially as the referee only sees the player who cries loudest. Soccer actors regularly make a spectacle of themselves hoping to draw a penalty, and the slightest tap by even an air molecule around an opponent causes the player to react like a gunshot victim. Medical units have rushed onto the field ready with a defibrillator as the wounded player howls in pain, only to see the injured player resume playing like nothing happened when the referee doesn’t buy it.

Legitimate complaint 4: The 90-minute length of the game can be brutal for those watching the clock. Unlike American football, where only 10 minutes is spent actually playing and the rest is used for close-ups on quarterbacks looking intense and the team planning their next play, there are no pauses in the soccer action. Other than halftime, there are no funny commercials to give viewers a chance to get another beer or relieve their bladders. Looking away even for a moment from the monotonous passing and midfield dribbling can mean missing the only goal scored the entire game.

Legitimate complaint 5: We’ll end on the low scores. In the first 16 matches, 25 goals were scored, 22 by Germany against Australia. Players like “England” goalkeeper Robert Green, an agent planted to give the U.S. a chance, are quick to blame the ball for being too much of a sphere and ruining their game. But low scores are as much a part of soccer as they were in baseball, before Mark McGwire made steroid use the league’s unofficial policy.

Soccer fans have three more weeks to convince their friends the sport is worth waking up at eight in the morning to watch. In doing so, it’s best to admit and apologize for these flaws, while chanting “U-S-A!”

Read more here: http://www.thebatt.com/opinion/finding-fault-with-football-1.1492869
Copyright 2026 The Battalion