Column: Plastic bags – Your two cents’ worth

By Taylor Casey

After years of debate, but little to no progress, Iowa City residents may no longer have to answer that repetitive question: “Paper or plastic?”

There are an astounding 500 billion to 1 trillion plastic bags used annually (which calculates out to approximately 1 million bags used per minute, or roughly 83,000 every five seconds), according to estimates by Worldwatch Institute, an environmental think tank. And sadly, only 1 to 2 percent of those plastic bags actually make their way to the recycling bins — which, let’s be honest, are infrequent and widely dispersed across the UI campus and nearly nonexistent downtown.

Jaw-dropping statistics such as these leave me absolutely awestricken that Iowa City is not following in California’s “green” footsteps by potentially banning the use of plastic bags.

If such a ban was implemented, I’m hopeful that not only would it discourage UI students from using excessive numbers of plastic bags carelessly, it would also largely reduce the pollution and waste dumped around the city by pressing residents to use reusable bags.

San Francisco is the first (and only) major U.S. city testing the effectiveness of such a ban, but the idea itself was first introduced to the United States by other nations, including South Africa, Ireland, China, and Bangladesh.

Subsequent to China’s decision to implement the ban on free plastic bags in 2008, decreased demand resulted in an estimated 40 billion unused bags, according to Worldwatch Institute. In effect, this reduced plastic bag consumption by 66 percent and saved roughly 1.6 million tons of petroleum.

San Francisco has had surprisingly optimistic results as well. In 2007, its initiative disallowing the use of plastic bags in major supermarkets and pharmacies ultimately promoted customers’ use of cloth or paper bags (the kind made from all natural, biodegradable, cornstarch-based plastic that are more environmentally friendly — not that organic kind cut directly out of the tree). The moment San Francisco decided to enforce the ban on anything but biodegradable bags, a 50 percent reduction in plastic bag litter on the streets was apparent.

We understand the local community may be apprehensive about the overall effectiveness of this initiative, but if San Francisco and even entire nations can have significantly lower plastic bag consumption, do the benefits not outweigh the risks?

A few locally owned Iowa City businesses have started making their own small efforts to become more eco-friendly. One shining example is the New Pioneer Food Co-op, 22 S. Van Buren St. New Pioneer is a cooperatively owned business that stresses its utmost concern with being environmentally aware of its products and packaging.

Jenifer Angerer, the New Pioneer marketing manager, wrote via e-mail, “New Pioneer does not support the use of either paper or plastic; we encourage people to bring their own bags and to reuse existing bags. We charge for both plastic and paper bags and give that money to the Crisis Center.”

Member services coordinator Theresa Carbrey said the store has made several successful pushes to encourage people to use the establishment’s wide variety of reusable bags. Members have been amazingly receptive and enthusiastic, she said, noting a significant reduction in the number of at-cost bags used.

With such local business owners touting only positive benefits, I’m hopeful that if the City Council considers a proposed ban sometime in the future, it will only encourage residents to become better acquainted with their reusable bags and get into the habit of taking them to the grocery store (then actually using them). Litter could be decreased dramatically; you could finally empty out that cabinet that’s overflowing with emptied post-shopping sacks.

There may be lingering doubts — especially considering the bulk of Iowa City’s population is dominated by carefree college students — but if the UI community took the ban seriously and followed through, we could drastically limit the unnecessary surplus of plastic bags. And with more than 1 million being used per minute, what’s one fewer bag really going to cost you?

Read more here: http://www.dailyiowan.com/2010/06/17/Opinions/17547.html
Copyright 2026 The Daily Iowan