The Iowa City New Pioneer Co-op is like an ancient pair of slippers to many of its members, Theresa Carbrey said. Charming, but tattered.
Carbrey and several other members — along with the store’s Board of Directors — gathered at the Iowa City Recreation Center on Wednesday night to take part in a discussion about whether to move from the Iowa City store’s current location, 22 S. Van Buren St.
The directors, as well as several members of the Co-op — all of whom also serve as co-owners — said they feel strongly that the current location’s small size is keeping the store from expanding to offer more products to Iowa City, where local food products are in high demand.
The directors said they are looking at several sites but said they could not share the locations.
Those in favor of moving locations also said they are concerned with the building’s vulnerability to flooding, noting it is near Ralston Creek, an area that flooded most recently during Tuesday’s flash floods.
While roughly half of the members present at the meeting supported the board moving forward with plans to find a new location, others said they are concerned building a new store would take away from the Co-op’s core traditions.
The store first took over a portion of the Van Buren location in 1977; ten years later, it expanded into the full site.
While some members labeled the South Van Buren site “the golden egg,” based on its unique charm, sense of community, and convenient location; others, such as Dean Abel — a 20-year member — went as far as describing the store as an albatross around the members’ necks.
“What will we do when the store floods?” Abel said, “Two more feet of water [than Tuesday’s flood], and we’re gone.”
But Jan Palmer, a 10-year member of the Co-op, maintained keeping the Van Buren store is important.
“The Van Buren store is a cultural anchor in Iowa City,” she said. “We need to keep the store not only out of respect for the store and its members but for respect of the community.”
The Van Buren location is becoming harder for employees to run, said Sarah Walz, the president of the Board of Directors for the New Pioneer Co-op.
Brad Lynch, 10-year Co-op member and employee, agreed, saying the problem is structural.
“There is no ability to put greener technology into the Van Buren building because of flood regulations,” Lynch said. “I would like to see a new store that provided ample space along with safe equipment in a safe location but still hold on to the community.”
Zara Wanlass, a seven-year Co-op member, reminded the concerned crowd that a new location is not all about size.
“We have to remember that expanding is not about being bigger but about what we can do for the local businesses selling their products in our store.”
All the debate, Carbrey said, is because the New Pioneer Co-op is a “democratic grocery store,” meaning that every person’s opinion on the store’s location can also be seen from a political perspective.
“We have grown and changed how things worked over the years,” Carbrey said of the store. “Each of us are deeply invested in the Co-op; we just have to be empowered to make this decision and move forward together as a group.”
And to the members of this local food store, that is what the store is all about: community.
The next Board of Directors meeting is scheduled for July, though the next discussion with members has yet to be set.