Ohio University sentenced its chapter of the Pi Beta Phi sorority to one year of probation and fined it less than $300 after a formal at a West Virginia art center allegedly caused more than $44,000 worth of damage.
During a June 11 administrative hearing, led by director of University Judiciaries Jim Sand, the chapter admitted to only some of the accusations brought against them by the Parkersburg Art Center, including stealing keg taps, spilling at least one plate of food and strewing toilet paper and paper towels in the bathroom.
In addition to the one-year probation, the sorority must also complete 20 hours of community service and pay a $290 fine to the art center – $200 for cleaning fees and $90 for the keg taps.
“The hearing officer didn’t feel like the severity of the behavior matched what was alleged,” said Dean of Students Ryan Lombardi. “The severity of the sanction was reflective of the level of behavior that was believed to have occurred.”
In a letter sent to the president of the OU sorority from Abby Hayhurst, the art center’s director, Hayhurst accused attendees of the March 6 winter formal of “using plates like missiles” in food fights, dancing in puddles of alcohol, engaging in public sex acts and ruining tablecloths and carpeting.
Two staff members from the art center testified during the hearing, and representatives from the sorority were also present, Lombardi said.
“I don’t think there was sufficient evidence presented to suggest that (their behavior) did rise to that level,” Lombardi said.
Now that the center has received $44,296 in insurance money, the decision of whether, when and whom to sue is in the hands of the West Virginia Board of Risk and Insurance Management, said Richard A. Hayhurst, lawyer for the art center and husband of its director.
“To (the Board of Risk and Insurance Management) the damages were legitimate,” said Diane Holley-Brown, director of communication for the board. “We are working with the insurer of the sorority … to investigate and seek reimbursement for the claim. It’s very premature to say anything in the line (of litigation) because everyone is working together to try to resolve it.”
The board mailed a check for $44,296 to the art center yesterday, Holley-Brown said.
Following the formal, the center brought in a commercial cleaning company to help clean up the mess, which included urinals filled with feces and vomit and chewing gum on the carpet, according to the letter. The letter also states the bartender hired for the event “feared for her safety” when guests attempted to tear off her clothing and take money out of her apron pocket.
“We support our Ohio Alpha chapter and its response to the three charges brought by Ohio University,” the national chapter of Pi Beta Phi said in a statement. “We also respect OU’s findings in the matter. The chapter will work collaboratively with Ohio University in honoring its community service requirements and university warning status for the following year.”
The national Pi Beta Phi sorority had previously said the claims were “grossly exaggerated” after the center threatened to sue affiliates of Pi Beta Phi for the full cost of damages in May. The center also kept the chapter’s $1,200 security deposit.