As city commissioners change Lawrence’s smoking ban to comply with a new state law, many businesses worry about inconveniencing bar and restaurant patrons when the new policy takes effect July 1.
City commissioners confirmed June 8 that it planned to update Lawrence’s existing regulations to comply with state law before it goes into effect on July 1. Six years after the city passed its ordinance, the state has outlined slightly different regulations in the Kansas Indoor Clean Air Act. Fixing the discrepancies between the two is now the primary concern, said Scott Miller, staff attorney of legal services for the city. The newest draft of city ordinance was presented at the City Commission meeting Tuesday.
“Some state regulations are more stringent than Lawrence law, some are less,” Miller said. “We are required by law to change the ordinance, if we’re going to have one, to incorporate those provisions that are stricter as defined by the state.”
State law more narrowly defines smoking near access points, banning smoking within a 10-foot radius of a doorway or window. This provision has significant implications on downtown business owners who don’t have the property necessary to accommodate regulations and maintain outdoor smoking areas. Frank Dorsey, manager of The Bourgeois Pig, said he expected the new law to affect business operations to a “huge extent.”
“The smoking sections available to people will basically be whittled down to only a few feet on both our front and back patios,” Dorsey said.
He said that though it affected the comfort and freedom of his patrons, he hoped that because all bars and restaurants would be facing the same problem, it wouldn’t hurt business significantly.
The problems it may create for downtown businesses initially are well worth the health benefits for supporters like Dr. Steven Bruner, who helped create the initial City ordinance in 2004.
“We’re really pleased the Commission chose not to go backward and repeal the City ordinance,” Bruner said. “Eliminating risks to nonsmokers by adopting the state law, with the added provisions, really gives us the best of both worlds.”
Bruner said the problem created for bars and restaurants in downtown Lawrence was a reasonable trade off to protect public health.
The updated smoking ban may remain an issue for some, but many students now appreciate the benefits of more stringent regulations. For supporters like Molly Easley, a graduate student from Lawrence, designated smoking areas away from business entrances are reasonable substitutes for outdoor patios that may subject nonsmokers to smoke inhalation
“While it might be inconvenient, it makes people more thoughtful about smoking around others,” Easley said. “I honestly think it should be up to the business owner, but I also understand the rationale behind wanting to protect people from secondhand smoke.”
Tobacco use is the leading cause of preventable disease for smokers, but Bruner said it also had significant drawbacks for nonsmokers. He said that secondhand smoke was associated with cardiovascular risk, but in cities with similar indoor smoking bans, the risk of heart attack decreased by 15 to 25 percent.
The University policy has defined its own regulations since 1993 and requires smokers to maintain a distance of 20 feet from doorways. Also effective on July 1, the campus will no longer allow the sale of tobacco products.