The acting scene lost one of its shining lights on Oct. 28, when Sir Patrick Stewart died after a short battle with Alzheimer’s and Lewy body disease at age 86. With his commanding stage presence and an ability to perform drama and comedy with equal grace, the Shakespearean actor achieved international recognition playing Captain Jean-Luc Picard in the Star Trek franchise and Professor X in the X-Men franchise, along with hundreds of other roles over the years. But while Stewart may have now taken his final voyage to the stars, he spent years dealing with mortality and the meaning of life in his acting roles. In honor of the actor whom fellow Star Trek star George Takei called “a true and irreplaceable legend,” here are seven performances that might help viewers cope with this loss.
“Star Trek: The Next Generation,” Season 6 Episode 15: “Tapestry”
The later seasons of “The Next Generation” are typically its strongest, and that holds true in this character study of Stewart’s iconic character, Captain Jean-Luc Picard. Shot in the chest on a diplomatic mission gone wrong, Picard flatlines on the operating table as the episode opens and is greeted in the apparent afterlife by Q, the all-powerful alien trickster played by recurring guest star John de Lancie. Q informs Picard that he died due to a malfunction in his artificial heart. Q offers Picard the chance to go back to his youth and fix the reckless mistake that led to him getting that heart, and Picard accepts. Aside from the crackling comic chemistry between Stewart’s no-nonsense captain and de Lancie’s impish immortal, the episode ultimately offers a profound look on how the things we regret just might be the things that weave the tapestry of our lives.
“A Christmas Carol”
Everyone knows the timeless tale of Ebenezer Scrooge and the Christmas night that the old miser was visited by spirits who caused him to change his ways. But Charles Dickens’ novella was especially important to Stewart, who even crafted his own one-man stage show interpretation that he performed on and off from 1988 until as recently as 2019 at various locales, including Broadway. For those of us who didn’t get a chance to see him live, he leaves several different ways to experience his passion, including a 1999 film adaption, a full audiobook reading and a series of TikTok and Instagram mini-readings. In all of these, Stewart richly conveys Scrooge’s confrontation with mortality and the transformational effect it has upon the miser. In the film version, for example, his wheezing laugh on Christmas morning gives the impression of a dead man gasping his way back to life, while in the readings Stewart’s familiar baritone immerses the listener in Dickens’ prose.
“Star Trek Generations”
The movie that took the Next Generation crew to the silver screen has attracted a mixed reception over the years, but Stewart got to play a Captain Picard suffering a midlife crisis after a terrible family tragedy: the death of his brother and nephew in a house fire.
“Recently, I’ve become aware that there are fewer days ahead than there are behind,” Picard confides to Marina Sirtis’ Counselor Troi when she comes to check on him shortly after he gets the news. This is a movie preoccupied with the finite nature of life, with Malcolm McDowell’s villain tempting Picard with the promise of immortal bliss at a terrible price. The lesson may be summed up in a single quote, delivered with characteristic soul by Stewart.
“I rather believe that time is a companion who goes with us on the journey and reminds us to cherish every moment, because they’ll never come again,” Picard says.
“Logan”
Although Stewart will return as Professor X for his final, posthumous appearance in December’s “Avengers: Doomsday,” this was his initial farewell performance to the iconic X-Men character. And what a performance it was. Playing a great man brought low by dementia, Stewart’s agonizing delivery of Xavier’s struggles cut deeper after the reveal of the actor’s own Alzheimer’s battle.
“I always know who you are. It’s just sometimes I don’t recognize you,” he laments to Wolverine. But Sir Patrick brings the old professor’s essential humanity to the fore in his lucid moments, giving soft yet firm advice to his old protege.
“You still have time,” he urges Hugh Jackman’s Wolverine as the former X-Man contemplates the prospect of having a normal, loving family, with the pain of a man who knows he himself no longer has any. It’s a compelling portrait of a man in his twilight years.
“Star Trek Picard,” Season 1, Episode 10: “Et in Arcadia Ego, Part 2”
Stewart’s return to Jean-Luc Picard came with a good deal of say in the character’s direction as an executive producer, and the show is full of great episodes exploring the character’s aging. But this episode in particular stands out, culminating a season-long arc where Picard faced a potentially terminal disease. Pushed to the limit, Picard seemingly sacrifices his own life to save a world … and is met in a strange liminal space by his old friend, Brent Spiner’s Commander Data, who perished in the film “Star Trek: Nemesis.” What follows is a rumination on the value of death.
“Mortality gives meaning to human life, Captain. Peace, love, friendship, these are precious, because we know they cannot endure,” the android reminds Picard, explaining why he considers dying to be the most crucial part of his quest to become more human. It’s a heartbreaking, yet peaceful scene of farewell.
“The Kid Who Would Be King”
A light-hearted adventure may seem an odd choice for this list, but even with his limited screentime, Stewart makes a big impact playing the true form of the wizard Merlin, who otherwise appears as a teenager played by Angus Imrie; Stewart takes over whenever it is time to impart a truly impactful lesson. Merlin has emerged to help young Alex confront the return of the evil Morgana Le Fay. But more than that, he is here to pass on the mantle to the next generation, to turn a phrase. He passes his wisdom on to Alex, knowing that his own long life nears the end of its usefulness.
“You and I are history, Morgana. The future is theirs, not ours,” he tells the villainous witch during the final battle at Alex’s school. While Morgana is busy trying to recapture her glory days, Merlin recognizes that the time of myths and legends like himself has come to an end, but that nonetheless the future is in good hands. Just as the children rise up to take up Merlin’s call, so too Sir Patrick will be an inspiration to actors for years to come.
“Star Trek: The Next Generation,” season 5, episode 25: “The Inner Light”
It feels only fitting to end on Patrick Stewart’s favorite Next Generation episode, and frankly, it’s a worthy choice. “The Inner Light” sees Captain Picard zapped by a strange alien probe, and he wakes up on another planet where everyone believes he is a simple weaver named Kamin. Though at first resistant, Picard gradually settles into this life, accepting that “Captain Jean-Luc Picard” was nothing more than a fever dream. Years pass, and we witness the full life of Kamin; Stewart’s commanding, emotional performance anchors the episode, giving the feel of a whole life squeezed into a 45 minute episode. It’s a deeply affecting story of a mundane life well-lived, one that makes the inevitable final twist a true gut punch. As we celebrate Stewart’s life, this tale of the beauty of living feels like a good place to end. Try — and fail — to hold back the tears at the final flute melody that plays over the end credits.