In July 2023, “Barbie” and “Oppenheimer” released on the same day, creating Barbenheimer, one of the biggest moviegoing phenomena in recent history. In November 2024, we got a knockoff of it in Glicked, the simultaneous release of “Wicked” and “Gladiator II.” Hollywood is trying to do it again as a month from now, on Dec. 18, we’ll be getting Dunesday, the simultaneous release of Denis Villeneuve’s “Dune: Part Three” and Marvel Studios’ “Avengers: Doomsday.” But I have no interest in this turning into another competition.
I’ll start by saying I don’t have anything against “Doomsday” or those excited to see it. I used to be just as excited about Marvel movies, but these are two films that shouldn’t be compared. One represents corporate products designed to generate hype and capitalize on brand recognition, while the other is the fulfilled creative ambition of an auteur filmmaker.
From “Avengers: Endgame” up until “Doomsday,” Marvel released dozens of movies and television productions, constantly expanding its cinematic universe. In May 2024, Disney CEO Bob Iger announced plans to reduce Marvel’s annual output, citing the need to focus more on quality. A sign of Marvel’s problems with overproduction, it leaves the Russo Brothers with the task of finishing a story that somehow has to be not only coherent but also satisfies any leftover plotline from previous shows and movies. It looks like a mess, and I don’t trust the Russos after 2025’s “The Electric State,” in which it was revealed they used artificial intelligence during its production.
In that same time period, Villeneuve gave us three “Dune” movies. This is a really good thing for the Dune franchise. Instead of flooding audiences with an endless stream of content, some of which was pretty bad, Villeneuve has spent eight years developing a cohesive story across three ambitious films.
What makes “Dune: Part Three” so exciting to me is the opportunity to see a creative vision that has remained remarkably consistent across three massive productions in just six years. The first two films have been incredible, and everything we’ve seen so far suggests “Part Three” will be no different. It’s surreal to see a trilogy of this scale not lose sight of the artistic vision behind it.
I’ve long been a fan of Frank Herbert’s universe. I’ve read half the novels, as well as watched “Part One” and “Part Two” maybe too many times. After years of carefully bringing Herbert’s universe to the big screen, Villeneuve has returned to the planet Arrakis to finish telling a story that has clearly meant so much to him. It’s the culmination of a filmmaker’s years-long commitment to a world he loves.
Marvel’s approach, on the other hand, has become increasingly dependent on audiences keeping up with an enormous collection of interconnected productions. One that, if we’re being honest, most don’t have time for. I would much rather see filmmakers given the freedom to make their movies without having to worry about the entire corporate universe that surrounds them.
One of my biggest issues with “Doomsday” is how heavily it relies on familiar faces. Following Jonathan Majors’ departure from Marvel, the studio had to reconsider its plans for Kang the Conqueror, whom Majors played. Rather than recasting the character, Marvel decided to pivot to using Doctor Doom as the film’s villain, bringing in Robert Downey Jr., who formerly played Iron Man, to play the character.
Downey is a fantastic actor, but this is clearly nothing more than nostalgia bait. Adding to this impression are the return of Chris Evans’ Captain America and the X-Men led by the late, great Patrick Stewart’s Professor X. Marvel is banking on audiences’ familiarity with these actors and the characters they’ve played before, hoping nostalgia alone will be enough to draw people back to theaters. Seriously, how can a team of professionals gather around a table and still allow this to move forward?
There’s a difference between bringing back a familiar face to generate excitement and bringing one back because the story calls for it. “Dune Part Three” features the return of Jason Momoa, who originally played Duncan Idaho in “Dune,” this time as the ghola Hayt, an artificial body created in the image of Idaho. Unlike Marvel’s decision to cast Downey in an entirely new role, Momoa’s return is rooted in Herbert’s “Dune Messiah,” the source material Villeneuve is adapting. Hayt’s identity and resemblance to Idaho are central to his character, which makes the return of Momoa a deliberate storytelling choice. It doesn’t capitalize on his popularity to sell tickets like Downey’s casting does.
There’s another problem with how Marvel is introducing its new villain: we’re being told to fear him before we’ve been given a reason to. The first official “Doomsday” trailer relies on Thor warning audiences about how dangerous Doom is, but what do we know about him in this version of the Marvel Cinematic Universe? Outside of his one appearance in the post-credit scene of “The Fantastic Four: First Steps,” not much.
Some might compare this to Thanos, which is fair, as he was also a relatively mysterious villain before “Infinity War.” But Thanos had already appeared in multiple earlier MCU films, and “Thor: Ragnarok” helped establish the scale of the threat heading toward the Avengers. These differences make it obvious Marvel had little plan for Doom. I understand that Doctor Doom is arguably the most famous villain in all of Marvel’s comics, but speaking purely from an MCU standpoint, what do we have to be excited for?
Meanwhile, “Dune Part Three” can rely on the two previous films to establish its characters, conflicts, setting and universe. Audiences already have a reason to be invested in what happens next, as the story has already been built. Even as Villeneuve introduces new characters, including Robert Pattinson’s Scytale, their presence serves the larger narrative rather than simply adding recognizable faces to the cast.
This brings me back to Dunesday. The conversation now is about which movie makes more money, which studio will win the weekend and whether Dune can compete with the Avengers.
Truthfully, I don’t want to care about this conversation, but it’s so hard to ignore. Marvel will be fine. Dune will be fine. These are two major franchises with established audiences that in some areas intersect. There’s no real reason to turn their release date into a financial measuring contest.
The legacy of the Dune franchise won’t depend on whether or not it outgrosses an Avengers movie. It probably won’t, but that doesn’t matter. For me, Dune is more important than the money it makes. “Dune: Part Two” is already regarded as one of the greatest science fiction movies of its generation. Steven Spielberg called it “one of the most brilliant science fiction films I’ve ever seen.” I don’t have the same credibility as Spielberg, but it’s one of my favorite movies of all time.
The IMAX conversation makes this even more tiring. “Dune: Part Three” secured an exclusive three-week IMAX window a year in advance, which makes sense for a film that shot 71 minutes of IMAX exclusive footage. Disney’s response has been to throw a temper tantrum and introduce Infinity Vision, a certification for existing premium theater formats such as Dolby Cinema. For all intents and purposes, it’s a fake format.
I get wanting “Doomsday” on the biggest and best screens possible, but if IMAX is so important to Disney, why not move the release date? There are other weekends available. Instead, we’re getting another branded format and more exhausting arguments about which studio deserves the biggest screens.
I hope “Doomsday” is good. I do. I’ll still go see it, and I hope Marvel gives its audiences something worth getting excited about. I just don’t want to spend the wait until the release of both movies arguing about which one deserves to make more money.
Barbenheimer was something special, and it hasn’t been truly recreated since. But Dunesday doesn’t need to recreate it either. Just because two movies share a release date doesn’t mean we have to turn them into opposing sides of a battle. It’s so tedious. This is not in the spirit of Barbenheimer! We went to see two movies on the same day to celebrate cinema, and both titans can coexist! Why do we have to turn everything into this annoying money conversation?
Despite this, I know what I’ll be doing on Dec. 18. I’ll be calling it Dune’s Day because I’ll watch “Dune” and call it a day.