
Nina To/The Cougar
On Oct. 29, a tragedy rocked the online world. The Fanfiction website Archive of Our Own announced it would be down for weeks due to a “security incident.”
After more than two weeks offline, AO3 returned on Nov. 15 with some features temporarily disabled as it continues to recover.
As AO3 battles this cyberattack, now is a good time to reflect on its legacy. The massive fanfiction hub has encouraged millions to read and write creatively.
However, its strong anti-censorship policy has drawn criticism for allowing obscene content, including sexual stories featuring underage characters.
Some argue that this writing is immoral and should be banned outright. Yet that raises the question: Who gets to decide what can be published? Historically, some have labeled queer themes as pedophilic, while extreme moral purists would prohibit all sexual content.
Anti-censorship strongholds like AO3 allow users to explore controversial topics, but disturbing content may be the price of creative freedom.
The grand central station of fandom and literacy
Since launching in 2009, AO3 has grown to more than 11 million registered users and 18 million fanworks across 77,000 fandoms.
Readers can go to high school with the My Little Pony cast, participate in their own Hunger Games or have their mom sell them to One Direction. It’s ridiculous, creative and often very frisky.
Amid youth literacy crises and AI tools stunting creativity, AO3 encourages millions to read and write, even if it’s amateur fanfiction about kissing Draco Malfoy.
AO3 also connects fandoms through crossovers, introducing readers to new media. I discovered Marvel through a Harry Potter crossover in 2014, sparking a years-long passion for a universe I barely knew existed.
Fiction has always been “problematic”
Controversial topics have always been included in literature. “Lolita” is told from the perspective of a pedophile, while Pulitzer Prize-winning “Beloved” depicts bestiality and sexual violence. Even mainstream shows like “Game of Thrones” feature incestuous relationships.
These stories depict disturbing subjects, yet they’re still shown on television or introduced to minors in school. I read “Beloved” in high school, and its graphic portrayal of slavery and sexual violence still sticks with me today.
It was the most disturbing book I had read at that point, but its haunting narrative enriched me as a writer. Even today, its lines echo in my imagination. Would I have benefited from being “protected” from material some find too horrific?
Classic literature proves that no topic should be off-limits in storytelling, as even disturbing subjects can be explored in artistically valuable ways.
The question of censorship
Unfortunately, there’s no denying that some fanfiction depicts grooming and child abuse merely for perversion’s sake, making it difficult to defend its literary merit. While banning such stories seems obvious to me, the fact that this is debated proves it is not so simple.
The biggest argument for keeping morally atrocious fanfictions available on AO3 is that all work allowed on the site is legal in the U.S. Since all depictions of abuse or hate are fictional, even when the characters are based on real people, everything is supposedly harmless, no matter how gross it may be.
Of course, legality should never be the standard for morality, and just because something is legal doesn’t make it okay. Similarly, writing and sharing sexual child abuse stories, even if they’re fictional, cannot be a sign of a healthy mind.
Consuming hundreds of such stories, which chronically online readers are known to do, would, at minimum, skew a reader’s perspective on what is and isn’t acceptable, even if they don’t act on it.
Furthermore, while fictional characters don’t mind being puppets of a grotesque imagination, real people who get fanfiction written about them—such as actors and celebrities—would no doubt be disturbed to know what people write about them doing.
Truthfully, there is no easy answer to the question of censorship. While certain stories on AO3 are immoral under my definition, they are just risqué fiction to others, and AO3 compromises by banning nothing and allowing everything.
For now, I will continue celebrating the positive contributions AO3 has made to the internet while skirting the dark sides erupting on it like spots of mold.
opinion@thedailycougar.com
—
“AO3 walks a fine line between creativity and censorship” was originally posted on The Cougar