Legal service organizations, ACLU sue ICE over policy hiding location of detainees

Legal service organizations, represented by the American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts, filed a lawsuit Oct. 28 challenging a new federal policy allowing U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement to hide the locations of thousands of detainees through its Online Detainee Locator System, which went into effect Sept. 15.

Protesters hold signs condemning U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement at a protest on Marsh Plaza. The American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts filed a lawsuit against the federal government, objecting to a new policy that allows ICE to hide the locations of detainees. (AVA RUBIN)

The lawsuit was filed by Greater Boston Legal Services, Rian Immigrant Center, Florence Immigrant and Refugee Rights Project and Amica Center for Immigrant Rights. The groups argue the policy “unlawfully blocks them from locating, communicating with, and providing legal services to their clients and potential clients,” according to an ACLU Massachusetts press release.

ACLU Massachusetts staff attorney Jennifer Herrmann said the absence of the online locator, a system which had been in place for 16 years, makes it near impossible for legal professionals to help their clients or find new ones.

“This is unlawful. It was implemented suddenly without any notice or legal justification, which is not permitted,” Herrmann said. “The law requires that the government provide adequate notice and explain its reasoning when making major policy changes like this. And the Trump administration did neither.” 

Sarah Sherman-Stokes, a clinical professor of law and associate director of the Immigrants’ Rights and Human Trafficking Clinic at the BU School of Law, said she used the detainee locator hundreds of times over her 15 years as an immigration lawyer. 

“It’s a really important tool in the toolbox to try to find someone when they’ve been detained, when they’ve been disappeared from their home or their work or off the street,” she said.

Sherman-Stokes said the government frequently moves ICE detainees away from where they were originally apprehended, separating them from family members and legal counsel and often leaving them in jurisdictions where the law is less favorable to immigrants. She said it is an intentional strategy by the Trump administration.

“It’s part of a pattern of lawlessness by ICE and this administration,” Sherman-Stokes said. “They want to make the process opaque. They want to make it difficult to find people,” 

ICE did not respond to a request for comment. 

The plaintiffs allege in the lawsuit the ICE policy is “arbitrary and capricious,” as well as a violation of the Administrative Procedure Act and the Freedom of Information Act.

“Arbitrary and capricious is a legal standard [for] when agencies take actions that are seemingly untethered from real policy or real articulable reasons.” Sherman-Stokes said “This policy certainly seems to satisfy both those criteria.” 

Herrmann said that the Freedom of Information Act requires that government agencies proactively disclose statements of policy and interpretations adopted by an agency and not published in the Federal Register. The location of detainees is included in FOIA requirements, she said.

Earlier this week, Democrats took control of Congress in the midterm elections, flipping the previous Republican majority. Sherman-Stokes said she hopes the Democratic legislature will be a check on the Trump administration’s immigration policies.

“I really hope that the Democrats taking control of the House and the Senate will be a check on the lawlessness of this presidency and, in particular, the way that this president has carried out really, really aggressive and illegal immigration tactics,” Sherman-Stokes said.

Herrmann said the ACLU would continue in the lawsuit to ensure that immigrants can get the legal assistance they need.

“We are fortunate in this Commonwealth to be home to many immigrants who are making up our society, and those people are among those who are being hidden by the federal government as a result of this policy, to the great detriment of our communities,” Herrmann said.

Read more here: https://dailyfreepress.com/11/05/23/222287/legal-service-organizations-aclu-sue-ice-over-policy-hiding-location-of-detainees/
Copyright 2026