Calling for violence against the Cornell rapists does not make you a better person

Originally Posted on The University News via UWIRE

It’s been over a month since Jane Doe filed a lawsuit against Cornell University, the Chi Phi fraternity and seven of its students: Matthew Ingalls, Johnathan Newell, Winston Lee, Gillio Lopes, Diego Sarabia, Scott Norris and Scott Kretzschmar. 

Other universities and institutions, content creators who speak on social justice, survivors and victims of rape and everyone imaginable made statements or posted videos discussing the allegations. Commenters demanded action. The list of the accused sevens’ names was widely reposted. “How can they walk free?” some asked. “Jail for life,” others demanded. “Kill them all,” some said with GIFs of knives and scissors.

I wonder, though, if people are saying these men deserve to die because they truly believe in these consequences, or if it is because death — and the thought of nonexistence, a removal of further and more complex consequences — is merely easier than the alternatives, and it provides the illusion that the work is done, releasing them of the responsibility of future work.

It can feel like speaking up to repost someone’s reel calling for us to “kill them all” and click like on some official statements about the horror of rape and every organization’s newly affirmed commitment to preventing those scenarios. It can feel like absolution from complicity in rape culture. You made it known that you think the situation is horrible; you think the men responsible deserve immediate and harsh punishment. That is enough, right?

Well, no. Not really. This short-circuits the extended effects of the case and its relevance to SLU’s campus. It’s the easy way out, because doing some more questioning and self-reflection will lead to uncomfortable places.

Probing further into the appropriate fate of the accused seven would require considering the legal proceedings of it all. To wonder what the courts should decide for them, and if the death penalty is truly what you desire.

It would also require one to contextualize these men as real, whole people. To think about the real social consequences of their actions, and what it would mean for them to continue to attend class or go to their jobs. As the New York Times detailed, only two of the six eligible men — one had graduated — were expelled. Norris and Kretzschmar got nothing but no contact orders, sexual harassment modules and the infamous “reflection essays.” And they still walk around campus now. Just as an accused rapist could have walked past you on West Pine today.

It would require, too, questions about the other 50 members of the Snapchat group who spectated or laughed at the entire situation. About why they didn’t make any attempt to stop the situation, question the circumstances, ask who Jane Doe was or if she was okay, publicly call out their fraternity brothers or report their actions.

It would require one to question the purpose and impact of fraternity and sorority life as a whole. It’s no secret that horrific scenarios of rape like this can take place at any college campus. And while this case’s details, like the screenshots of other fraternity brothers reacting to the “free pussy” and reports of all seven doing lines of ketamine from Jane Doe’s unconscious body, are especially shocking, they are not unique. This is not new. It’s just the case where the internet drew the line.

There have been 28 reported cases of rape on SLU’s campus in the last three years, according to the 2026 Annual Security and Fire Safety Report. There have almost certainly been dozens more that went unreported.

When you call for them to all be killed, does that apply to the guy in line next to you at Qdoba? The guy who sits in your psych class? The guy in your club, on your floor, in your fraternity? In your group chat, who talks about the girls he’s trying to sleep with? At your dinner table? In your inner circle?

When you say you denounce the whole situation and that you stand with Jane Doe, do you listen to women when they say they don’t want to hang around certain men or go to certain places? When they say they’re in danger? When they open up about their prior experiences? Do you call out a frat guy’s questionable language and stories when he recounts them, publicly and immediately?

And when you inevitably answer no — what could possibly be stopping you?

Self-reflection and nuanced conversations on incidents of rape are necessary for preventing it in the future, and in your own circles. I know the perceived extremism and desire for justice that comes from typing we should kill all the rapists makes you feel all heroic and supremely feminist. But your comments mean nothing in real life if you’ve ever secretly wondered how drunk a girl was and if it was really that bad after hearing what happened to her at Humphrey’s.

The actual best response you can have doesn’t come from what you repost, but what you say to your friends. Get braver. Get meaner. Call out the behaviors that have become all too normal on campus. Understand who is more vulnerable to sexual assault and rape, and where, and when. And please, for the sake of the Jane Doe in your study group and for the world we all must live in, have some damn empathy.

Read more here: https://unewsonline.com/2026/11/calling-for-violence-against-the-cornell-rapists-does-not-make-you-a-better-person/
Copyright 2026 The University News