I think it’s obvious to anyone who reads my work that I have a healthy respect for public policy.
Although it may be hard to fathom some days, I do believe the government can be a force of good when leaders want it to be. I even wrote a column on how we depend on government resources more than we think!
Unfortunately, there exists an evergreen idea that I see pop up again and again: That many public services are just a money pit and could be cut or privatized without issue.
It’s genuinely shocking how many people I’ve seen try to frame the fact that government services like the post office cost money as losing money when that mindset fundamentally misunderstands the point of public services.
Senior fellow at the University of Minnesota Humphrey School of Public Affairs and former state budget official Jim Schowalter said while there are absolutely services that can be provided through privatization, public services still serve as a backdrop to our lives, from the water we drink to the trash we throw away.
“These things, you don’t think about them,” Schowalter said. “You don’t think about the regulation for the electrical grid. You only think about the grant programs, or the legislature, or the political fights, yet on a daily basis, public servants and public services are making sure things work.”
Even in my reverence for all things publicly funded, I still forgot to keep things like electricity and our sewage systems in mind when initially thinking about this column. Turns out, public services are quite the load-bearing pillar of our society!
Schowalter said when thinking about public services, the true value of a service is often not seen because the cost of not having a particular public service is frequently not considered. Thus, finding a way to promote both the subtle benefits of public services and the role that taxpayers play in paying for those benefits may be helpful.
“There’s an important idea called the ‘tragedy of the commons,’ where some things that would help everyone be better off may not be individually well-financed, but everyone comes out better,” Schowalter said. “That’s an example where the postal service and other central services may not necessarily cover the cost of their services, but without them, you have an even bigger problem.”
One policy area that I adore yet has seen the sour side of public debate is public transit. I cannot count the number of times I have heard debates asking if public transit is worth the large amounts of money such projects can cost.
Director of fiscal research for the Humphrey School’s Institute for Urban and Regional Infrastructure Finance Camila Fonseca Sarmiento said public transit systems can bring social, environmental and economic benefits from commuters being able to take jobs further away to fewer cars and less traffic on the roads.
“When we talk about big projects like the Light Rail, that also brings economic benefits in the sense that it’s kind of changing what the area used to be,” Fonseca Sarmiento said. “Before, let’s say it was mostly residential, but now we’re seeing some areas that are also commercial. People have the opportunity to come, and that also brings economic development to the area.”
Humphrey School infrastructure policy researcher Kaitlyn Denten said the availability of public transit can also have positive effects on an individual’s financial life, and in turn, on the economy as a whole.
“When individuals are able to spend less money on their personal vehicles, as personal vehicles are generally expensive, they’re able to use those dollars for different things,” Denten said. “Whether that’s groceries, whether that’s choice purchases, those kinds of pieces help economically.”
I myself have saved plenty of gas thanks to the Light Rail and Metro Transit, not to mention how many classes I’ve been able to make it to on time by popping on a Green Line train.
Though they may be harder to quantify, the benefits of maneuverability, convenience and traffic avoidance should not be overlooked.
Fonseca Sarmiento said despite the fact that a large portion of public transit funding is garnered through taxes instead of fares and in spite of lower ridership since the COVID-19 pandemic, all of the different economic and environmental benefits that come from having developed public transit systems outweigh the cost in tax funding.
“Showing that additional value that we’ve told you about has been hard,” Fonseca Sarmiento said. “So now the research we’re conducting is on how to communicate the value of public transit away from ridership.”
Public services are, in essence, suffering from their own success. They have become so ubiquitous that their benefits are easy to overlook, leaving our focus on their price tag.
Fonseca Sarmiento said public services in general can have an advantage over private ones, as private enterprises often can’t coordinate terribly well or provide many of the same services at inexpensive costs to the everyday consumer.
“Something that we’ve been discussing in the meetings and events we’ve been having is ‘What would have happened if the service was not provided?’” Fonseca Sarmiento said. “And that’s where we hear people saying, ‘Oh, we needed that.’”
The point of government is not to be profitable. The point of government is to be beneficial to the most people it can be, and sometimes, achieving that goal costs money.
We all benefit from many of the services that are provided to us thanks to our tax dollars and the work of dedicated public employees, and I think we owe it to ourselves to take a moment and appreciate what we’ve built together instead of haggling over how we can save a few dollars.
Public services belong to all of us, after all. Let’s keep it that way.
The post Opinion: Public services deserve our respect appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.