Elizabeth Holmes, founder of the now defunct medical technology company Theranos, is no stranger to media discussions, being the subject of multiple major news scandals and even a hit television show, all criticizing her actions to defraud investors and steal millions. So while a documentary focused on her time before jail was not surprising, the documentary’s level of depth truly was.
“You Can See Everything” follows Elizabeth Holmes and her husband, Billy Evans, in the month before she is required to go to jail, where documentarians Lance Oppenheim and Nathan Fielder spend amounts of time with the strange couple, giving audiences a truly never-before-seen level of disclosure into the lives of their family; particularly, how they try to move on after being sentenced to prison and banned from the scientific community.
Nathan Fielder, creator of comedy series “Nathan For You” and “The Rehearsal,” truly felt like the perfect person to follow Holmes and her husband, with his lack of subtlety and extremely direct questioning making it very difficult for the duo to hide the truth. Fielder demonstrates how a real person reacts to talking to these people that think they’ve done nothing wrong, and captures his real reactions when hearing Holmes say she wants to try again. The juxtaposition between Holmes’ delusional belief that she could actually scam investors again while at the same time believing she was never at fault makes her conversations with Fielder extremely fascinating to watch.
One of the best aspects of this documentary is that the creators have worked hard to make you feel empathy for Holmes while still not giving her an out from the truly despicable things that she did. Her company, focused on creating technological innovations in the medical sector, gained massive fame before even delivering a single product, and after she was discovered scamming investors, was able to shift the blame to her then-boyfriend and co-founder, Sunny Balwani. This level of subterfuge makes it almost impossible to tell when Holmes’ emotions in this documentary are real vs a show for the cameras, showing how truly sinister she is.
While the first half of the film is focused on the 30 days before she is set to go to jail, the second half takes place two years after, and is truly where the audience is given a strange and insanely deep look into the minds of Fielder and Holmes and her family, specifically her husband Evans. Fielder shows how Evans manages to take control of his wife’s entire story and use it for his personal gain, making her seem trapped , but the most terrifying part is that it’s unclear how much Holmes is pulling the strings behind the scenes.
The second half acts as a deconstruction of Holmes as a person and how it can be difficult to understand a person who never shows their true self. Fielder goes deeply into understanding Holmes as a person and why she chose him to cover her story, despite his previous experience with comedic television.
It’s rare for a documentary to start to turn into a narrative film, but the level of unbelievability, especially in the second half, blurs the lines between reality and fiction. Fielder starts meeting with actress Amanda Seyfried, who played Holmes in the Hulu series “The Dropout,” which focused on the creation of her company Theranos and Holmes’ meteoric fall from grace. Working with Seyfried, the duo begins to recreate aspects of the unfilmed conversations Fielder had with Holmes and Evans. This gives the audience another perspective for the strange behaviors of Holmes, now from someone directly attempting to emulate her, and makes the documentary even more unnerving.
Despite the documentary’s almost three-hour-long runtime, it never really feels long, with Fielder and Oppenheim employing savvy editing tactics to constantly carry the story along. It is clear that they had hundreds of hours of footage, and did their best to fit as much of it into the run time without making the film feel clogged.
The idea that one of the greatest films of the year is a real-life documentary sounds absurd, but truly must be seen to be believed. “You Can See Everything” takes everything amazing about Fielder and Oppenheim’s narrative techniques and combines them with the absolute lunacy of Holmes and her family in a spectacle that is impossible to look away from.