Opinion: The death penalty is no longer acceptable

Originally Posted on The Minnesota Daily via UWIRE

Since a trip to Washington, D.C., when I was in high school, I have carried around a copy of the United States Constitution in the front pouch of my backpack. 

On occasion, whenever I’m bored or fidgety, I’ll flip through the pages and idly peruse the paragraphs that form the very heart of our nation. At the bottom of page 34 sits the Eighth Amendment, a single sentence smushed by the text above it.

“Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted.”

This sentence has set the tone for American justice since the days of the Founding Fathers. However, this raises a question: Are punishments in the U.S. really not cruel or unusual?

Unfortunately, we don’t have to look very far for examples of punishments that have caused serious pain or bodily harm. In September, Tennessee tried to execute Christa Pike for murdering her classmate in 1995. 

This execution did not go to plan, however, and Pike ended up surviving both doses of pentobarbital, staying on a ventilator for several days before regaining consciousness. She reportedly suffered from pneumonia and a blood clot in her arm when she awoke.

This horrifically botched execution calls into question the merits of capital punishment. As of 2025, 27 states still allow for the death penalty as a criminal sentence, yet Pike’s case was hardly the first time an execution has gone wrong.

Amy Bergquist, associate director of the International Justice program at the Advocates for Human Rights organization, said many execution methods end up being essentially non-medical experts experimenting on prisoners. Some executions deemed successful showed signs of a slower and torturous death, such as fluid in the lungs.

“People who are opposed to the death penalty aren’t opposed to accountability,” Bergquist said. “If a person has committed a crime, there should be consequences. But we also believe that all people, even if they’ve done bad things, should be treated with dignity, and there is really no way to carry out the death penalty in a way that respects dignity.”

In fact, a botched execution is the reason why Minnesota has not had the death penalty on the books for more than a century, as the law was changed a few years after a St. Paul man took 14 minutes to die by hanging in 1906.

Even though we remain the state with the largest mass execution in U.S. history, we still had the foresight to abolish the death penalty in 1911, and that says a lot about the severity of the concerns regarding execution methods.

Beyond awful and frequently botched execution methods, we also must address the fact that having the death penalty assumes our justice system is perfect, which it very much is not.

Bergquist said not only does the finality of the death penalty cause issues for those falsely convicted, but there has also been research suggesting that having the death penalty on the table can lead to those wrongfully accused of crimes to falsely confess to avoid execution.

“Our legal system makes mistakes, and the death penalty is in fact final once it is carried out,” Bergquist said. “Human beings are fallible, and our legal system is fallible, and we should account for that on both ends.”

According to data from the non-profit Death Penalty Information Center, 203 people have been exonerated from death row since 1973. The center estimates that this is one person for every eight executions carried out in the U.S.

And those are just the ones who were found to be innocent before their executions. It’s impossible to know for sure just how many innocent Americans have been put to death.

Given the horrendous methods used for executions, the significant likelihood of executing an innocent person, and the fact that a substantial majority of surveyed criminologists said the death penalty was not a deterrent for crime, we have to ask ourselves what the point is of having the death penalty at all.

Bergquist said if the goal is to help the families of victims of crimes like murder, governmental support should not just extend to one symbolic event, but should focus on continued assistance and resources to help families continue to live their lives.

“The United States is not in good company when you look at countries that are actively carrying out executions,” Bergquist said. “We’re in the company of countries like Iran, Saudi Arabia, Egypt, China. Those are the other countries that are carrying out executions, and I don’t think that’s anything to be proud of.”

Overall, I can understand why the death penalty may be an appealing punishment for many. Some crimes are simply unforgivable, with devastating consequences and irreparable damage caused.

However, the scale of the problems with capital punishment is simply too large to ignore. We all know that our government frequently makes mistakes, and our legal system makes plenty of errors too.

So then why would we trust the legal system to decide who should and should not die?

We are fortunate enough to live in Minnesota, a state that had incredible foresight on this topic a century ago.

But until a national ban on the death penalty is developed, the single-sentence amendment that promises humane punishment at the hands of the U.S. legal system rings hollow, like a promise waiting to be fulfilled.

The post Opinion: The death penalty is no longer acceptable appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.

Read more here: https://mndaily.com/opinion/opinion-the-death-penalty-is-no-longer-acceptable/10/28/2026/eicmndaily-com/
Copyright 2026 The Minnesota Daily