Gaviglio: The guilt tripping in tipping

Originally Posted on Daily Emerald via UWIRE

You may have heard the sentiment “If you can’t afford to tip, don’t go out.” The truth is, if the employer can’t afford to pay a living wage without relying on subsidies from the public, then they can’t afford to be in business.

Tipping is really only expected in the United States and Canada, and while tipping exists elsewhere, it is not expected; businesses still thrive. Clare Pashak, a 21-year-old advertising student at the University of Oregon, who studied abroad in Amsterdam, spoke on the lack of tipping in Europe. “I think the lack of tips is proof that the businesses are paying their employees enough,” Pashak said.

The tipping system punishes the very people it underpays. Clare Daudelin, a 21-year-old planning, public policy and management major at UO, said, “All of the jobs I’ve pretty much ever had have been in the food service industry … so, my mindset is what goes around comes around.”

Many service workers share this sentiment: not wanting to blame the business that employs them for the system it supports.

Everyone has been in the process of paying for overpriced coffee when the barista turns the iPad evaround and says, “It’s just going to ask you a couple of questions.” Then you’re met with the inevitable screen where you can choose 15%, 20%, custom tip or the evil no-tip button. If you’re the average person, you seldom, if ever, press the no-tip button because the guilt would be far too extreme.

This is because in America, customers are expected to make up a portion of workers’ salaries through tips. Some people believe that not tipping your server is a way of protesting the system. It is in no way your server’s fault; don’t punish them!

They are just another cog in the very large and historical machine that has built tipping culture.

Tipping became a practice in European taverns in the medieval era as a way to reward good service or to simply show how rich one was. Americans then discovered it for themselves around the 1850s, during travels to Europe, and took it back to America as a way to appear aristocratic. This practice was not without intense pushback by many Americans.

“The case against tipping was captured in William Rufus Scott’s 1916 anti-tipping polemic, ‘The Itching Palm,’ a book that railed against the practice and its negative impacts on society. The movement had momentum: anti-tipping associations were formed and anti-tipping laws passed,” according to NPR’s ‘Throughline’ podcast.

This anti-tipping movement failed, as daily American life shows. With the rise of tipping, business owners saw an opportunity to pay service workers the least amount possible, with the notion that it would be made up through tips.

“It’s a more nuanced topic than just whether or not it is morally right to tip. Is it morally right for businesses to underpay their employees and expect their customers to pick up the slack?” Pashak said.

Please do tip. However, tipping should return back to what it once was: a form of pure gratuity and appreciation, not necessity.

The post Gaviglio: The guilt tripping in tipping appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Read more here: https://dailyemerald.com/193338/opinion/gaviglio-the-guilt-tripping-in-tipping/
Copyright 2026 Daily Emerald