On Oct. 6, Bloomington Police Chief Booker Hodges held a press conference to address an uptick in gun violence linked to local Somali American gangs.
During the conference, Hodges used several visual aids, including a printed still from “Malibu’s Most Wanted,” the 2003 comedy starring “B-Rad,” the hood-culture-obsessed son of a wealthy Florida senator, whom Hodges likened to the alleged criminals.
Hodges drew the comparison because he said the young men the department is investigating supposedly come from two-parent homes, live in expensive apartments with “$3,500-a-month rent” and drive “Beamers, and Mercedes and all these luxury cars”.
“These kids have come from good homes, and they have money,” Hodges said. “They’re living in houses that cost more than my mortgage. So they’re out here simply shooting each other based on social media beef. Period. That’s it.”
Later in the conference, Hodges told reporters he had no idea where the root of the problem lies, as recent incidents defy the typical link between poverty and gang violence that he witnessed growing up throughout Black and Latino communities in north Minneapolis.
In his closing remarks, Hodges reiterated law enforcement’s commitment to curbing gang violence endangering the public and keeping these young men from growing old.
While his concern reads genuine, parents will continue to bury their sons if public discourse remains entrenched in the notion that poverty and violent crime are inextricably linked — forcing the struggles of Somali American youth into antiquated molds of gang-related shootouts over who controls what corner and “B-Rads” romanticizing their plight to disrupt the maddening sterility of Middle American life.
Poverty alone does not beget gang violence.
An unlocked bike. The back aisle of a corner store. An unsuspecting cashier. All of these offer an immediate reprieve without help from anyone else. Money earned through gang life is not paid up front, if ever paid at all.
But status, validation and belonging are felt from day one.
How presumptuous to see a young man come home to dinner and assume he’s content just for having a seat at the table. How naive to think a Mercedes emancipates the driver from generations of war, scarcity and displacement.
What does the distance between cinder-block projects and quiet cul-de-sacs matter to children whose fathers are an ocean away? And could joking about gangsters in Shakopee while holding a Malibu’s Most Wanted poster undermine the entire issue?
Jasim Abdi, a volunteer teacher at Abubakar As-Saddique Islamic Center, said the teens in his classes have ambitions, but feel hindered by a lack of generational knowledge regarding navigating American institutions. He said the priority at this stage is to provide concrete stepping stones toward their goals, such as completing student aid applications and applying for college.
“They don’t know someone that’s been there or done that,” Abdi said. “So to them, it looks impossible even though it’s not.”
Along with navigating American institutions, many are also left navigating complicated familial situations.
Although family ties are strong in Somali culture and divorce is relatively rare, economic pressure renders many households effectively run by single mothers. The demands of providing for their families, both at home and abroad, often leave fathers overextended and largely absent from their children’s lives.
This dynamic destabilizes families, sometimes manifesting in cycles of self-destructive behavior and paternal estrangement.
A young Somali man who operates a family restaurant said when he was growing up, his father spent weeks at a time driving semitrucks and made frequent trips back home to care for his mother, sometimes for up to six months.
Though he asked not to be identified due to his role and familial conditions, he said the role of family was complicated for him growing up. He grew resentful of his father’s abrupt departures amid critical times for the family and would often lash out under pressure. In turn, their relationship tapered into purely sporadic, angry phone calls for months on end.
If the gap between who teens are and who they want to be is not bridged by someone with their best interests at heart, it will be by someone who does not. The more they feel disconnected from one or both parents, growing up without “those smiles, those laughs, those afternoon walks,” as Abdi described it, the more that risk increases.
However, that’s not to say children who grow up within limited support systems cannot learn self-reliance and build successful futures. University fourth-year Anisa Ismael said young women in particular have embraced higher education, especially in healthcare.
“Women are more self-starters,” said Ismael. “Their frontal lobe develops faster, and they’re more excited for their education because in Somalia the men were prioritized.”
While young men are equally capable, without a proper support system, they can be more vulnerable to peer pressure. This challenge is universal, but intervening can be more complicated for Somali families, even when both parents are present.
Messages between first-generation children and immigrant parents are easily lost in translation. Growing up speaking different languages and being socialized into different cultures, gaps in communication form along generational lines, often widening with time.
Imam Yusuf Abdulle said this dynamic contributes to a fractured identity that emerges when children grow up in constant negotiation between worlds of competing influences.
“At school, playground or basketball courts, they are American kids,” Abdulle said. “When they come home, they are Somali kids.”
The harder different identities pull in opposite directions, the harder it becomes to pursue a life that reflects a coherent sense of self. When you don’t know who you are, where you come from or where you’re going, it’s easy to forget what you have to lose.
When police release a mugshot showing more creases on the subject’s jumpsuit than on his face, the tragedy isn’t how that reflects on Minnesota or the Somali community, but that a young man lost his life and another, his future.
Eden Prairie Police Chief Matt Sackett was correct in his statement following Hodges’ address when he said, “We can’t fix a problem unless we’re truly defining the problem”.
Shying away from uncomfortable conversations that could ultimately protect sons, brothers and friends does a disservice to the people in our community currently grieving theirs.
We can hold two truths at once.
We can seek answers to keep a few disillusioned young men out of harm’s way without fueling political rhetoric weaponized against the entire Somali diaspora. We can ask why young men are dying, how we can prevent it and why it’s more complex than “social media beef”.
Minnesota will never develop real solutions if our only approach is either stereotypes and speculation or ignoring the problem altogether.
As Imam Abdulle said, “We need to talk to each other, not about each other.”
The post Opinion: Escaping contrived ideas about Somali American gang violence appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.