Modern cinephiles diagnosed: Franchise fatigue

Originally Posted on The Cougar via UWIRE

Amy Montanez/The Cougar

The 2020s have had a huge impact on pop culture, more specifically, movies. The beginning of this decade was a dark time for movies and life in general due to COVID-19, but eventually productions resumed. 

With this resumption, a pattern began to form: an influx of installments to already established franchises. A fall of new, original characters and stories performing well at the box office.

Sequels, prequels, spinoffs and reboots make up a large portion of this decade’s highest-grossing films. 

A decline in interest and excitement for long-tenured franchises is the result of franchise fatigue, but is franchise fatigue actually negative? Or does it light a fire under the butts of movie studios to produce new and original characters?

Fatigue on the big screens

Franchise fatigue greatly affects large production companies as opposed to smaller independent ones. The Walt Disney company is one of the best examples of this. Disney owns 2 of the largest franchises in the world: Marvel and Star Wars. Marvel alone has thirty-eight movies within the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU), plus their mini-series and shorts. 

Star Wars falls just short of that number in movies and series but still totals a similar amount. With viewers becoming disinterested in larger, pre-established franchises, they take the brunt of the consequences. 

Despite the recent success of “Spider-Man: Brave New World”, Marvel movies are making considerably less money at the box office than before. Out of the last 6 Marvel movie releases, only 2 of them performed as highly as expected. There is a similar pattern with Star Wars: “Star Wars: The Mandalorian and Grogu”, their most recent film, is officially the lowest-grossing Star Wars film ever. 

Disney franchises aren’t the only ones suffering from this pattern: “Scream 7” received poor reviews due to its overreliance on nostalgia as opposed to a fresh story and “Joker: Folie à Deux” had critics and fans feeling it had an underwhelming conclusion and was an unnecessary installment. Both of these films performed at lower levels in the box office than their predecessors.

Growth in creativity 

Now this isn’t to say that any newly produced franchise installment is going to perform poorly. The entire reason for the incursion of franchise installments by major companies was because these movies were performing well. 

There was a point in film that recognizable IP meant a guaranteed chart topper. It was more profitable to use characters people were already familiar with and had consistent fan bases, rather than take a chance on a new character. 

But as we enter the latter part of the decade, on the heels of a new one, there’s been a shift in what audiences want to see. There have always been filmmakers making new original movies, but now we see them breaking box office records and being favored over existing IP.

This year, we’re seeing more high-grossing original movies. Out of all of the films ranked number one at the box office for this year, eight of them are of new stories audiences aren’t familiar with. This may not be significant, but compared to 2023, there were three and six in 2024; we already have more original films 9 months into the year than previous years at their conclusion. 

Looking at these numbers, it’s hard to see franchise fatigue as something negative. This year, we’ve gotten the directorial debut of Curry Barker with “Obsession” and Kane Parsons with “Backrooms” and the return of huge names Sam Raimi, Christopher Nolan and Stephen Spielberg, all of which have managed to get many people back in theaters. 

An end to the exhaust

When the conversation of franchise fatigue comes up, there is plenty of blame on Hollywood for constantly reproducing the same tired stories and franchises, but studios keep producing them because up until recently they were performing well.  If studios see that people are beginning to flock towards original stories, that’s what you’ll begin to see more of.

Hollywood follows where the money’s at. 

There is only one cure for franchise fatigue and it’s to go see something else! The demand for original stories is still high, yet so is the amount of upcoming releases drawn from existing IP. The recent success of these original stories can be taken as a small step towards seeing more perform well at the box office. 

If this pattern continues, new actors and directors will have a chance to debut, giving Gen Alpha a chance to get their own characters instead of recycled ones. 

The failure and underperformance of franchise installments can promote the importance of new, original ideas in the box office that represent unique perspectives and not the same old, same old.

opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“Modern cinephiles diagnosed: Franchise fatigue” was originally posted on The Cougar

Read more here: https://thedailycougar.com/2026/10/12/modern-cinephiles-diagnosed-franchise-fatigue/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=modern-cinephiles-diagnosed-franchise-fatigue
Copyright 2026 The Cougar