Few institutions today are as monstrous as the American prison. You don’t even need to be a dyed-in-the-wool leftist to notice its various iniquities: chronic overcrowding, woefully inadequate medical care, horrifying levels of sexual violence, the use of torture as a means of punishment. Whatever else one might think of it, incarceration in our country is an almost uniquely savage proposition — not just by our own standards but globally as well.
Given this, many have not unreasonably asked: Does there exist an alternative?
According to the abolitionist movement, the answer is a resounding yes. Brought to the fore by the 1971 Attica prison riots, this heterodox wing of progressive thought claims that incarceration causes immense harm in exchange for essentially zero long-term gain. The supposed reason for this is that it does nothing to address the “root causes” of crime — most commonly, poverty and racism — the idea being that we can more effectively keep people safe by addressing those root causes instead of the effects they produce.
While it sounds nice in theory, the abolitionist project gets several points wrong. Several of these — not least the focus on “root causes” — have already been belabored by thinkers sharper than I, however, so instead of relitigating them, I’d like to wager a potentially more radical critique:
Despite the great deal of attention it pays to them, abolitionism fundamentally misunderstands what prisons even exist to do.
Confused? Let me explain. Although we like to think of them as exclusively punitive institutions, in at least one important regard prisons actually serve a protective function for our society’s worst elements. To understand how, consider the counterfactual.
Imagine that a member of your community has just murdered your daughter. Seeing red, you’d naturally like nothing more than for him to be brought to justice — but how? In the absence of a court system that can reliably apprehend, try and punish him, he’d logically be allowed to walk free. At first, all hope seems lost, but then you notice a useful corollary: Whatever you end up doing, you can expect to walk free too.
So, you settle for the next best option. You kill him.
The point here isn’t that the above scenario would unfold for 100% of crime victims. Rather, it would unfold for a sufficiently large number of them that the result would almost certainly be unbridled chaos — and indeed, this is precisely what we observe empirically. From inner-city turf wars to mafia conflicts to blood feuds in South Africa, almost everywhere that the state struggles to penalize wrongdoers the alternative is a Hobbesian war of all against all.
But didn’t we used to have other ways of sating the demand for punishment? Indeed we did, but most of these weren’t significantly more pleasant than incarceration: public beatings, destruction of one’s home, blinding, mutilation, banishment, hanging. To an extent abolitionists recognize this. Writer Christopher Glazek admitted forthrightly that “A prisonless society where murderers were systematically executed and rapists were automatically castrated wouldn’t be the most humane society imaginable, but it would be light-years ahead of the status quo.”
So it might be. But if our aim is to treat both the victims and the perpetrators of crime ethically, then rushing to deploy extreme force against the latter likely isn’t the way to go. Instead, the best equilibrium may just be an updated version of the status quo: constrain the use of punishment through due process and incarceration, but align conditions for prisoners with those expected of a civilized society. That way, we could affirm the humanity of our criminals while protecting them from the harms they’d suffer if we let them off the leash.