When freshmen stepped into their residence halls this year, instead of being met with resident assistants, community safety assistants and community assistants — several of them first-years — led the way.
In spring 2025, UO announced they would be splitting the traditional RA into two separate roles starting this academic year: community assistants and community safety assistants. Neither positions’ room and board are fully covered, CAs receive 65% and CSAs 85% off.
When hiring opened for the academic year, interest in the job was low.
“I didn’t get a single resident that wanted to be an RA after I told them about the changes,” Nathan Pratt, a former RA who chose not to return to the position, said.
The CAs fulfill the community-building aspect of the job by planning social events, making door decor and creating themed bulletin boards. In turn, the CSAs perform on-call duties, working in 12- or 24-hour shifts to respond to safety or security concerns according to a UO employee position description.
Legacy RAs, also known as Community Coordinators, occupy Unthank Hall and the Living Learning Center, maintaining the traditional role. Next year, these positions will cease to exist.
“RA is a universal term,” Cyrus DeWitt, a CC in Unthank, said. “If you’re introducing yourself during move-in, you are not going to go up to the parents and say, ‘Hi, I’m the CA.’ You’re going to say ‘I’m the RA.’ That’s what the parents know and what the freshmen know.”
First-year resident Xochitl Ponce-Juergens said she wouldn’t be able to describe the distinction between the CA and CSA positions.
“I don’t know. I wish I could tell you,” she said. “Most people don’t really think of them as CAs unless they are actively doing a CA duty, which doesn’t seem to be super often.”
Identifying CAs is increasingly difficult, particularly when many of these positions — 40% according to UO spokesperson Angela Seydel — are filled by fellow freshmen.
As a result, it is common for CAs to share a room with a non-CA freshman. CSAs are afforded their own single rooms. Julian Ohlinger, a freshman CA in Justice Bean Hall, said he finds this dynamic to be “a little awkward” for making friends.
There is “a little tension” Ohlinger said, for example, when he has to remind residents his own age to keep the noise down.
“I feel like it would be a strange experience as a freshman because you’re trying to have all these college first time things, but you’re also a resident assistant,” Blake Hovenkotter, a sophomore CA, said. “Everybody else might think, ‘Oh, you’re the narc, so I’m not going to invite you to things.’”
Beyond the potential for interpersonal conflict, previous RAs worry freshman CAs do not have ample experience to guide first-years.
“The whole thing about being an RA is that you’ve been on campus for a year. You’ve lived in the dorms, you know what resources are around and how to find them,” DeWitt said. “These freshmen that are coming in, they don’t know anything about campus, let alone how to help others navigate it.”
Additionally, many previous RAs find the line between the two roles blurred. When it comes to reporting policy violations, Hovenkotter said he’s “a little bit fuzzy” on who reports what.
“They were very clear we are not crisis response people,” he said.
To Hovenkotter’s understanding, CAs are still required to report policy violations, but he’s unclear when direct intervention is necessary.
Diego Alvarado, a sophomore CSA, said CAs cannot confiscate anything or unlock residents’ doors in case of a lockout. Instead, they must contact a CSA.
An added challenge to this new system is that CSAs now operate in zones, responding to incidents across two or three buildings. During on-call shifts, CSAs keep their phone ringtones on in case a resident calls to report an emergency, lockout, noise complaint or policy violation. They also conduct regular rounds, in which they patrol each residential floor.
Residence halls are grouped into four zones. Carson, Earl, and Yasui halls; Cedar and Justice Bean halls; and Global Scholars and Kalapuya Ilihi halls make up the zones staffed by CSAs. Living Learning Center and Unthank Hall are staffed by CCs.
As a result, DeWitt said, there is a delay in CSAs’ arrival, taking upwards of 15 minutes.
“What if there’s a medical emergency going on?” DeWitt said. “What if we can’t be there because we’re running across campus?”
According to Seydel, CAs are unable to authorize medical personnel access to residential rooms. That is left to the CSAs, CCs and other on-call staff.
Despite collaboration between the two positions being essential, communication has been minimal. During the weeklong training, CAs and CSAs were not officially introduced to one another, Alvarado said. He has no CA phone numbers or emails.
The split roles were not budget-driven, Seydel said.
“Our restructuring has aimed to be ‘budget neutral,’ meaning we are allocating the same amount of financial resources with this new model as we did with the previous model,” she said.
Years ago, Seydel said, RAs said they felt overwhelmed by the role. As a result, the new positions were created in Article 7 of UO Student Workers’ first contract.
DeWitt is doubtful, blaming the recent budget deficit and low enrollment numbers.
“It’s just another source of revenue. You’re getting thousands of dollars from these employees,” DeWitt said. “It’s solely for the pockets of housing and I can’t really see it as any other way than that.”
In the spring, the CSA position was fully staffed. Hiring for the CA position had to be reopened on April 17 and remained “open until filled,” closing in August. Seven CA spots are still vacant, Seydel said.
“It was very clear that they wanted upperclassmen and they had to open it to freshmen,” Hovenkotter said.
In spite of best efforts to relieve the workload via the alternative model, DeWitt said the number of residents they cover jumped from 46 in the previous year to 78 this year. A few coworkers, DeWitt said, have upwards of 60 or 90 residents.
CSAs are responsible for up to 1,529 residents in the largest zone — Justice Bean and Cedar.
Pratt said he misses being in the role.
“I really loved it, and I appreciated the connection to the students and getting to have an actual impact on their lives,” he said. “I definitely don’t miss getting calls at 1 a.m. or getting knocked on my door every day of the week.”
But despite the late-night calls, Pratt said, “If everything went back to normal, I’d still feel jaded, but I would become an RA again.”
The post Frustrations grow over new RA structure appeared first on Daily Emerald.