Opinion: Finding a fitting new name for 216 Pillsbury Drive

Originally Posted on The Minnesota Daily via UWIRE

Dean Edward Nicholson had his namesake stripped from the lecture hall now called 216 Pillsbury Drive in June 2024 after seven years of protest and debate surrounding his unscrupulous legacy. 

Nicholson’s tenure as dean ended in 1941, and his corruption largely faded from memory until the 2017 exhibit “A Campus Divided: Progressive Anti-Communist and Anti-Semitism at the University of Minnesota 1930-1942” exposed flagrant First Amendment violations, particularly targeting Black and Jewish students involved in antiwar, labor and civil rights politics. 

His efforts to suppress campus activism involved a long arc of collaborating with state and federal operatives to infiltrate and surveil left-wing student organizations, intercept students’ mail and disclose their sensitive information. 

These revelations sparked campuswide protests to rename Nicholson Hall and other buildings dedicated to controversial campus figures. The movement was amplified by national debates surrounding Confederate monuments and the Unite the Right rally in Charlottesville, Virginia, which occurred just days after the exhibit was unveiled. 

Riv-Ellen Prell, the curator of the exhibit, said although the project became absorbed into a broader narrative, it was neither explicitly ideological nor intended to argue a particular position. 

“I was interested in starting discussion,” Prell said. “Let’s talk about who these people were. Let’s talk about who we honor.”

The unanimous approval from the University’s Board of Regents to remove Nicholson’s name ultimately settled the conversation on that point. 

Nicholson Hall now going by its street address is an improvement to be sure, but it lacks a certain collegiate ring and is easy to confuse with its next-door neighbor, Pillsbury Hall.

It would be better, at least for the sake of consistency, for the Board of Regents to find a replacement. 

Given that Nicholson disgraced his reputation by violating students’ First Amendment rights, an apt replacement would be free-speech activist Mary Beth Tinker, co-plaintiff in the landmark Supreme Court case Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District.

The case arose after she, her brother and a friend were barred from wearing black armbands bearing peace signs to school in protest of the Vietnam War. The resulting 7-2 decision established that K-12 students and teachers retain their First Amendment rights on public school grounds, provided their speech causes “no material and substantial disruption.”

As Justice Abe Fortas famously wrote, “It can hardly be argued that either students or teachers shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gate.” 

Tinker was just 16 when those words were written. Ever since, she has made it her life’s work to advocate for students’ First Amendment rights, hosting speaking engagements on high school and college campuses across the country — most recently at the University in 2014. 

First Amendment lawyer and Director of the Silha Center for the Study of Media Ethics and Law Jeff Kosseff said Tinker v. Des Moines is unique in that the plaintiffs set an important precedent to uphold First Amendment protections while expressing a well-supported moral position. 

“In a lot of free speech cases, the people claiming the free speech rights are not necessarily great people because our First Amendment protects a lot of very abhorrent speech,” Kosseff said. 

Figures like Xavier Alvarez, who falsely claimed to have received the Congressional Medal of Honor, also served to broaden our constitutional protections, albeit in a way that makes carving his name into the side of a building a questionable choice. 

Alvarez’s actions were not exactly aligned with the regents’ criteria for a figure who “exemplifies the highest aspirations of the institution’s mission and guiding principles”.

Still, any refinement to the First Amendment is indispensably valuable. Freedom of speech is no longer unalienable if it doesn’t extend to society’s greatest heretic.

Unfortunately, the University often self-sabotages in that regard, both culturally and institutionally. The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression ranked the University 204th out of 261 colleges and universities in the 2027 College Free Speech Ranking.

The organization cited members of the University’s Planned Parenthood Generation Action chapter disrupting an event hosted by anti-abortion activist Avanelle Mitchell, alongside the University’s choice to rescind professor of Holocaust and Genocide Studies Raz Segal’s appointment to faculty director following a statement calling Israeli military action in Gaza “a textbook case of genocide,” as evidence of their ranking.

These sorts of initiatives are often justified by people who say that hate has no place on campus. But what qualifies as hateful? And what better place is there to find out?

The fringe, offensive and vile should always be heard, at least as an exercise in establishing free-speech principles. When the University fails to facilitate the free exchange of ideas, campus becomes nothing but a mid-tier country club. 

To endure as an academic institution, the University must act like one. Its history of failing to protect dissenting views ought to be transformed into a commitment to the opposite. Regarding the blank sign on Pillsbury Drive with “Nicholson Hall” still faintly visible, perhaps the Board of Regents would do well to adopt the fake it till you make it approach. 

If censorship is wrong enough to warrant removing Nicholson’s name, then opposing it must be important enough to put Tinker’s name, or some similar figure’s name, in its place. In cases like these, History often resonates more deeply when told through the lens of a key figure rather than the broader concept they represent. 

When was the last time you considered that Pioneer and Frontier Hall bear their names because University President Lotus Coffman believed the land underneath was ordained to the white Minnesotan and unworthy of the Indigenous people? 

Had those dorms been named Ramsey and Sibley Hall, the issue would have been settled years ago. 

Today, Tinker herself has become synonymous with a key First Amendment protection for students. Just ask the L1 students on East Bank memorizing the “Tinker Test” for their Constitutional Law course. 

For this, the Board of Regents should honor their commitment to defending what Nicholson attacked, and what the University has done less than everything to uphold.

The post Opinion: Finding a fitting new name for 216 Pillsbury Drive appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.

Read more here: https://mndaily.com/opinion/opinion-finding-a-fitting-new-name-for-216-pillsbury-drive/10/01/2026/eicmndaily-com/
Copyright 2026 The Minnesota Daily

Opinion: Finding a fitting new name for 216 Pillsbury Drive

Originally Posted on The Minnesota Daily via UWIRE

Dean Edward Nicholson had his namesake stripped from the lecture hall now called 216 Pillsbury Drive in June 2024 after seven years of protest and debate surrounding his unscrupulous legacy. 

Nicholson’s tenure as dean ended in 1941, and his corruption largely faded from memory until the 2017 exhibit “A Campus Divided: Progressive Anti-Communist and Anti-Semitism at the University of Minnesota 1930-1942” exposed flagrant First Amendment violations, particularly targeting Black and Jewish students involved in antiwar, labor and civil rights politics. 

His efforts to suppress campus activism involved a long arc of collaborating with state and federal operatives to infiltrate and surveil left-wing student organizations, intercept students’ mail and disclose their sensitive information. 

These revelations sparked campuswide protests to rename Nicholson Hall and other buildings dedicated to controversial campus figures. The movement was amplified by national debates surrounding Confederate monuments and the Unite the Right rally in Charlottesville, Virginia, which occurred just days after the exhibit was unveiled. 

Riv-Ellen Prell, the curator of the exhibit, said although the project became absorbed into a broader narrative, it was neither explicitly ideological nor intended to argue a particular position. 

“I was interested in starting discussion,” Prell said. “Let’s talk about who these people were. Let’s talk about who we honor.”

The unanimous approval from the University’s Board of Regents to remove Nicholson’s name ultimately settled the conversation on that point. 

Nicholson Hall now going by its street address is an improvement to be sure, but it lacks a certain collegiate ring and is easy to confuse with its next-door neighbor, Pillsbury Hall.

It would be better, at least for the sake of consistency, for the Board of Regents to find a replacement. 

Given that Nicholson disgraced his reputation by violating students’ First Amendment rights, an apt replacement would be free-speech activist Mary Beth Tinker, co-plaintiff in the landmark Supreme Court case Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District.

The case arose after she, her brother and a friend were barred from wearing black armbands bearing peace signs to school in protest of the Vietnam War. The resulting 7-2 decision established that K-12 students and teachers retain their First Amendment rights on public school grounds, provided their speech causes “no material and substantial disruption.”

As Justice Abe Fortas famously wrote, “It can hardly be argued that either students or teachers shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gate.” 

Tinker was just 16 when those words were written. Ever since, she has made it her life’s work to advocate for students’ First Amendment rights, hosting speaking engagements on high school and college campuses across the country — most recently at the University in 2014. 

First Amendment lawyer and Director of the Silha Center for the Study of Media Ethics and Law Jeff Kosseff said Tinker v. Des Moines is unique in that the plaintiffs set an important precedent to uphold First Amendment protections while expressing a well-supported moral position. 

“In a lot of free speech cases, the people claiming the free speech rights are not necessarily great people because our First Amendment protects a lot of very abhorrent speech,” Kosseff said. 

Figures like Xavier Alvarez, who falsely claimed to have received the Congressional Medal of Honor, also served to broaden our constitutional protections, albeit in a way that makes carving his name into the side of a building a questionable choice. 

Alvarez’s actions were not exactly aligned with the regents’ criteria for a figure who “exemplifies the highest aspirations of the institution’s mission and guiding principles”.

Still, any refinement to the First Amendment is indispensably valuable. Freedom of speech is no longer unalienable if it doesn’t extend to society’s greatest heretic.

Unfortunately, the University often self-sabotages in that regard, both culturally and institutionally. The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression ranked the University 204th out of 261 colleges and universities in the 2027 College Free Speech Ranking.

The organization cited members of the University’s Planned Parenthood Generation Action chapter disrupting an event hosted by anti-abortion activist Avanelle Mitchell, alongside the University’s choice to rescind professor of Holocaust and Genocide Studies Raz Segal’s appointment to faculty director following a statement calling Israeli military action in Gaza “a textbook case of genocide,” as evidence of their ranking.

These sorts of initiatives are often justified by people who say that hate has no place on campus. But what qualifies as hateful? And what better place is there to find out?

The fringe, offensive and vile should always be heard, at least as an exercise in establishing free-speech principles. When the University fails to facilitate the free exchange of ideas, campus becomes nothing but a mid-tier country club. 

To endure as an academic institution, the University must act like one. Its history of failing to protect dissenting views ought to be transformed into a commitment to the opposite. Regarding the blank sign on Pillsbury Drive with “Nicholson Hall” still faintly visible, perhaps the Board of Regents would do well to adopt the fake it till you make it approach. 

If censorship is wrong enough to warrant removing Nicholson’s name, then opposing it must be important enough to put Tinker’s name, or some similar figure’s name, in its place. In cases like these, History often resonates more deeply when told through the lens of a key figure rather than the broader concept they represent. 

When was the last time you considered that Pioneer and Frontier Hall bear their names because University President Lotus Coffman believed the land underneath was ordained to the white Minnesotan and unworthy of the Indigenous people? 

Had those dorms been named Ramsey and Sibley Hall, the issue would have been settled years ago. 

Today, Tinker herself has become synonymous with a key First Amendment protection for students. Just ask the L1 students on East Bank memorizing the “Tinker Test” for their Constitutional Law course. 

For this, the Board of Regents should honor their commitment to defending what Nicholson attacked, and what the University has done less than everything to uphold.

The post Opinion: Finding a fitting new name for 216 Pillsbury Drive appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.

Read more here: https://mndaily.com/opinion/opinion-finding-a-fitting-new-name-for-216-pillsbury-drive/10/01/2026/eicmndaily-com/
Copyright 2026 The Minnesota Daily

Opinion: Finding a fitting new name for 216 Pillsbury Drive

Originally Posted on The Minnesota Daily via UWIRE

Dean Edward Nicholson had his namesake stripped from the lecture hall now called 216 Pillsbury Drive in June 2024 after seven years of protest and debate surrounding his unscrupulous legacy. 

Nicholson’s tenure as dean ended in 1941, and his corruption largely faded from memory until the 2017 exhibit “A Campus Divided: Progressive Anti-Communist and Anti-Semitism at the University of Minnesota 1930-1942” exposed flagrant First Amendment violations, particularly targeting Black and Jewish students involved in antiwar, labor and civil rights politics. 

His efforts to suppress campus activism involved a long arc of collaborating with state and federal operatives to infiltrate and surveil left-wing student organizations, intercept students’ mail and disclose their sensitive information. 

These revelations sparked campuswide protests to rename Nicholson Hall and other buildings dedicated to controversial campus figures. The movement was amplified by national debates surrounding Confederate monuments and the Unite the Right rally in Charlottesville, Virginia, which occurred just days after the exhibit was unveiled. 

Riv-Ellen Prell, the curator of the exhibit, said although the project became absorbed into a broader narrative, it was neither explicitly ideological nor intended to argue a particular position. 

“I was interested in starting discussion,” Prell said. “Let’s talk about who these people were. Let’s talk about who we honor.”

The unanimous approval from the University’s Board of Regents to remove Nicholson’s name ultimately settled the conversation on that point. 

Nicholson Hall now going by its street address is an improvement to be sure, but it lacks a certain collegiate ring and is easy to confuse with its next-door neighbor, Pillsbury Hall.

It would be better, at least for the sake of consistency, for the Board of Regents to find a replacement. 

Given that Nicholson disgraced his reputation by violating students’ First Amendment rights, an apt replacement would be free-speech activist Mary Beth Tinker, co-plaintiff in the landmark Supreme Court case Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District.

The case arose after she, her brother and a friend were barred from wearing black armbands bearing peace signs to school in protest of the Vietnam War. The resulting 7-2 decision established that K-12 students and teachers retain their First Amendment rights on public school grounds, provided their speech causes “no material and substantial disruption.”

As Justice Abe Fortas famously wrote, “It can hardly be argued that either students or teachers shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gate.” 

Tinker was just 16 when those words were written. Ever since, she has made it her life’s work to advocate for students’ First Amendment rights, hosting speaking engagements on high school and college campuses across the country — most recently at the University in 2014. 

First Amendment lawyer and Director of the Silha Center for the Study of Media Ethics and Law Jeff Kosseff said Tinker v. Des Moines is unique in that the plaintiffs set an important precedent to uphold First Amendment protections while expressing a well-supported moral position. 

“In a lot of free speech cases, the people claiming the free speech rights are not necessarily great people because our First Amendment protects a lot of very abhorrent speech,” Kosseff said. 

Figures like Xavier Alvarez, who falsely claimed to have received the Congressional Medal of Honor, also served to broaden our constitutional protections, albeit in a way that makes carving his name into the side of a building a questionable choice. 

Alvarez’s actions were not exactly aligned with the regents’ criteria for a figure who “exemplifies the highest aspirations of the institution’s mission and guiding principles”.

Still, any refinement to the First Amendment is indispensably valuable. Freedom of speech is no longer unalienable if it doesn’t extend to society’s greatest heretic.

Unfortunately, the University often self-sabotages in that regard, both culturally and institutionally. The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression ranked the University 204th out of 261 colleges and universities in the 2027 College Free Speech Ranking.

The organization cited members of the University’s Planned Parenthood Generation Action chapter disrupting an event hosted by anti-abortion activist Avanelle Mitchell, alongside the University’s choice to rescind professor of Holocaust and Genocide Studies Raz Segal’s appointment to faculty director following a statement calling Israeli military action in Gaza “a textbook case of genocide,” as evidence of their ranking.

These sorts of initiatives are often justified by people who say that hate has no place on campus. But what qualifies as hateful? And what better place is there to find out?

The fringe, offensive and vile should always be heard, at least as an exercise in establishing free-speech principles. When the University fails to facilitate the free exchange of ideas, campus becomes nothing but a mid-tier country club. 

To endure as an academic institution, the University must act like one. Its history of failing to protect dissenting views ought to be transformed into a commitment to the opposite. Regarding the blank sign on Pillsbury Drive with “Nicholson Hall” still faintly visible, perhaps the Board of Regents would do well to adopt the fake it till you make it approach. 

If censorship is wrong enough to warrant removing Nicholson’s name, then opposing it must be important enough to put Tinker’s name, or some similar figure’s name, in its place. In cases like these, History often resonates more deeply when told through the lens of a key figure rather than the broader concept they represent. 

When was the last time you considered that Pioneer and Frontier Hall bear their names because University President Lotus Coffman believed the land underneath was ordained to the white Minnesotan and unworthy of the Indigenous people? 

Had those dorms been named Ramsey and Sibley Hall, the issue would have been settled years ago. 

Today, Tinker herself has become synonymous with a key First Amendment protection for students. Just ask the L1 students on East Bank memorizing the “Tinker Test” for their Constitutional Law course. 

For this, the Board of Regents should honor their commitment to defending what Nicholson attacked, and what the University has done less than everything to uphold.

The post Opinion: Finding a fitting new name for 216 Pillsbury Drive appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.

Read more here: https://mndaily.com/opinion/opinion-finding-a-fitting-new-name-for-216-pillsbury-drive/10/01/2026/eicmndaily-com/
Copyright 2026 The Minnesota Daily

Opinion: Finding a fitting new name for 216 Pillsbury Drive

Originally Posted on The Minnesota Daily via UWIRE

Dean Edward Nicholson had his namesake stripped from the lecture hall now called 216 Pillsbury Drive in June 2024 after seven years of protest and debate surrounding his unscrupulous legacy. 

Nicholson’s tenure as dean ended in 1941, and his corruption largely faded from memory until the 2017 exhibit “A Campus Divided: Progressive Anti-Communist and Anti-Semitism at the University of Minnesota 1930-1942” exposed flagrant First Amendment violations, particularly targeting Black and Jewish students involved in antiwar, labor and civil rights politics. 

His efforts to suppress campus activism involved a long arc of collaborating with state and federal operatives to infiltrate and surveil left-wing student organizations, intercept students’ mail and disclose their sensitive information. 

These revelations sparked campuswide protests to rename Nicholson Hall and other buildings dedicated to controversial campus figures. The movement was amplified by national debates surrounding Confederate monuments and the Unite the Right rally in Charlottesville, Virginia, which occurred just days after the exhibit was unveiled. 

Riv-Ellen Prell, the curator of the exhibit, said although the project became absorbed into a broader narrative, it was neither explicitly ideological nor intended to argue a particular position. 

“I was interested in starting discussion,” Prell said. “Let’s talk about who these people were. Let’s talk about who we honor.”

The unanimous approval from the University’s Board of Regents to remove Nicholson’s name ultimately settled the conversation on that point. 

Nicholson Hall now going by its street address is an improvement to be sure, but it lacks a certain collegiate ring and is easy to confuse with its next-door neighbor, Pillsbury Hall.

It would be better, at least for the sake of consistency, for the Board of Regents to find a replacement. 

Given that Nicholson disgraced his reputation by violating students’ First Amendment rights, an apt replacement would be free-speech activist Mary Beth Tinker, co-plaintiff in the landmark Supreme Court case Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District.

The case arose after she, her brother and a friend were barred from wearing black armbands bearing peace signs to school in protest of the Vietnam War. The resulting 7-2 decision established that K-12 students and teachers retain their First Amendment rights on public school grounds, provided their speech causes “no material and substantial disruption.”

As Justice Abe Fortas famously wrote, “It can hardly be argued that either students or teachers shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gate.” 

Tinker was just 16 when those words were written. Ever since, she has made it her life’s work to advocate for students’ First Amendment rights, hosting speaking engagements on high school and college campuses across the country — most recently at the University in 2014. 

First Amendment lawyer and Director of the Silha Center for the Study of Media Ethics and Law Jeff Kosseff said Tinker v. Des Moines is unique in that the plaintiffs set an important precedent to uphold First Amendment protections while expressing a well-supported moral position. 

“In a lot of free speech cases, the people claiming the free speech rights are not necessarily great people because our First Amendment protects a lot of very abhorrent speech,” Kosseff said. 

Figures like Xavier Alvarez, who falsely claimed to have received the Congressional Medal of Honor, also served to broaden our constitutional protections, albeit in a way that makes carving his name into the side of a building a questionable choice. 

Alvarez’s actions were not exactly aligned with the regents’ criteria for a figure who “exemplifies the highest aspirations of the institution’s mission and guiding principles”.

Still, any refinement to the First Amendment is indispensably valuable. Freedom of speech is no longer unalienable if it doesn’t extend to society’s greatest heretic.

Unfortunately, the University often self-sabotages in that regard, both culturally and institutionally. The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression ranked the University 204th out of 261 colleges and universities in the 2027 College Free Speech Ranking.

The organization cited members of the University’s Planned Parenthood Generation Action chapter disrupting an event hosted by anti-abortion activist Avanelle Mitchell, alongside the University’s choice to rescind professor of Holocaust and Genocide Studies Raz Segal’s appointment to faculty director following a statement calling Israeli military action in Gaza “a textbook case of genocide,” as evidence of their ranking.

These sorts of initiatives are often justified by people who say that hate has no place on campus. But what qualifies as hateful? And what better place is there to find out?

The fringe, offensive and vile should always be heard, at least as an exercise in establishing free-speech principles. When the University fails to facilitate the free exchange of ideas, campus becomes nothing but a mid-tier country club. 

To endure as an academic institution, the University must act like one. Its history of failing to protect dissenting views ought to be transformed into a commitment to the opposite. Regarding the blank sign on Pillsbury Drive with “Nicholson Hall” still faintly visible, perhaps the Board of Regents would do well to adopt the fake it till you make it approach. 

If censorship is wrong enough to warrant removing Nicholson’s name, then opposing it must be important enough to put Tinker’s name, or some similar figure’s name, in its place. In cases like these, History often resonates more deeply when told through the lens of a key figure rather than the broader concept they represent. 

When was the last time you considered that Pioneer and Frontier Hall bear their names because University President Lotus Coffman believed the land underneath was ordained to the white Minnesotan and unworthy of the Indigenous people? 

Had those dorms been named Ramsey and Sibley Hall, the issue would have been settled years ago. 

Today, Tinker herself has become synonymous with a key First Amendment protection for students. Just ask the L1 students on East Bank memorizing the “Tinker Test” for their Constitutional Law course. 

For this, the Board of Regents should honor their commitment to defending what Nicholson attacked, and what the University has done less than everything to uphold.

The post Opinion: Finding a fitting new name for 216 Pillsbury Drive appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.

Read more here: https://mndaily.com/opinion/opinion-finding-a-fitting-new-name-for-216-pillsbury-drive/10/01/2026/eicmndaily-com/
Copyright 2026 The Minnesota Daily