The University of Minnesota Police Department decided to remove a Flock Safety camera near the West Bank campus after neighborhood residents raised concerns earlier this month.
In a statement, the University told the Minnesota Daily that the UMPD has been using Flock cameras for strictly public safety purposes, with data protection and compliance of the technology meeting state standards. Automatic license plate reader technology has been a valuable component of the University’s public safety commitment, they said.
The University also said working with Flock Safety has been critical in recovering stolen vehicles, aiding in violent crime investigations and locating missing persons. Leveraging this technology has also allowed officers to intercept criminal activity before it escalates, according to the University.
“All data is owned exclusively by UMPD, strictly audited monthly and automatically purged after 30 days,” the statement read. “Access is restricted to Minnesota law enforcement agencies and out-of-state agencies are only granted access on a case-by-case basis.”
While this is the first removal of cameras on campus, the UMPD operates 14 more on and around the campus area, according to the Minnesota Department of Public Safety.
A Star Tribune investigation in July found that U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement was able to access Flock data despite a Minnesota law mandating that the data only be shared for criminal investigations and not civil immigration enforcement. Despite this, the University states UMPD policy prohibits the technology’s use by ICE or any partnering agency.
ALPRs are features on Flock Safety cameras that record information about passing vehicles. Minnesota state law, statute 13.824, permits these ALPRs to collect license plate numbers, date, time and location data of vehicles passing by. They also take pictures of license plates, vehicles and the surrounding areas.
UMPD said that its devices do not use facial recognition, motion tracking or gunshot detection. Additionally, they said that all of the cameras’ ALPR data is owned exclusively by UMPD. Other law enforcement agencies cannot immediately access them unless upon request.
While this is the first removal of cameras on campus, the UMPD still operates 14 more on and around the campus area, according to the Minnesota Department of Public Safety. Their seemingly all-knowing presence has left students feeling nothing but uneasy.
For some students, the presence of these cameras around campus has felt like surveillance of their day-to-day lives. With the true nature of the cameras coming under widespread scrutiny, some feel they represent a growing effort of governmental supervision.
Second-year student Mohamed Muhudiin was glad to hear the camera would be removed. While he can understand why police use license plate readers, Muhudiin was uncomfortable with the amount of information they collect about students’ travel and whereabouts. He also worries about who can access that information, and whether a mistake could wrongfully connect someone to a criminal investigation.
Julie Shaw, a fourth-year anthropology student, said she does not think Flock cameras should be installed on a college campus.
“I wasn’t informed, and I wasn’t necessarily in on that decision as a student part of the student body,” Shaw said.
The University said UMPD reviewed existing security measures and other neighborhood-specific factors after receiving feedback from West Bank community members. It decided removing the Cedar-Riverside camera would support community trust while maintaining safety coverage.
Shaw said she was glad people spoke up and that the University listened. Still, she wants students to hear about decisions involving surveillance before a camera goes up rather than learning about them afterwards.
“I think definitely a public statement would be a good start,” Shaw said.
Shaw added that she wants the University to explain what happens to already collected information when a camera is removed.
Still, University officals hope this change can help to improve community relations. Looking to the future, the UMPD said it is committed to working with the community to build trust.
“UMPD determined that removing this single unit was the appropriate step to support community trust while maintaining robust safety coverage,” the statement read. “Our decisions are always guided by the best interests of our community and the University, and UMPD is committed to engaging and collaborating with stakeholders on any future security technology installations.”
The post UMN removes Flock Safety camera on campus, though multiple remain appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.