Debunking the myth that free will exists | Psych You Thought

Let’s set something straight. The “sweet treat” that you decided to order last night was not some ground-breaking example of you exercising your free will. In fact, neither was randomly deciding to take a day trip to Cambridge. 

The Merriam-Webster Dictionary describes free will as the “freedom of humans to make choices that are not determined by prior causes or by divine intervention.” However, because of its very definition, free will is impossible for humans to attain. 

Each action that you perform is preceded by the thought of what you are trying to accomplish with said action. You do not wake up in the morning, get ready for class and walk out of your door without thinking about the end goal — in this case, going to school — whether it is subconscious or not. Therefore, the idea of humans not considering prior causes when making decisions is inherently wrong. 

While it was not as common a couple of decades ago, the term has since reemerged in light of the 2025 TikTok trend “exercising my free will,” where people posted videos of themselves being “chaotic” or “spontaneous.” Little do they know, the very act of being intentionally impulsive for a clip defeats the whole purpose of practicing free will. 

In my first TikTok search for “exercising my free will,” I came across a video by user @gracegarrity, who flew to Florida because the UV level was at a staggering 10. Likely, she had already booked a ticket months prior and was posing as a spontaneous person. This misinterpretation could unfortunately inspire others to act the same way, or even feel envious of her apparent spontaneity. 

“Comparison is the thief of joy” is a common proverb, but it’s true — especially in today’s society. Dwelling upon the free-spirited nature of other people that you may observe online is never a healthy habit. It is likely that they are presenting their choices in a way that paints them as more spontaneous or appreciative of their free will than they truly are.

I believe many people would argue that they often go through their day, making choices without giving them any thought at all. They make their bed, pour creamer in their coffee, lace up their shoes and leave the house.

But the reason that they used the creamer they did was because they knew they enjoyed the caramel flavor. And their bed is made because they knew there would be people over later that night. Their shoes are tied because they knew they would be walking around campus all day and wanted to avoid sandals.

The concept of free will is challenged by a much more convincing term: determinism. This is the idea that all choices are made based on preceding events or forced by the laws of nature. It is more than plausible that your genetics, childhood and brain functions had more of an effect on your decision making than a split second choice. 

It is not often you go throughout your day mindlessly wandering. More often, you will find that you wake up with intentions for the days or goals you would like to accomplish. Intention  makes your time over the years more fulfilling and meaningful. If you disagree, I encourage you to practice determinism more often and base your choices on where you would like to be in the future.

The last thing that you need to inspire you to be spontaneous is a nonsensible TikTok trend. Go out and try things you would not normally choose. Test the limits of your comfort zone. Just remember that no matter how spur of the moment you think you are, everything you do is based on the past.

Read more here: https://dailyfreepress.com/09/26/13/220949/debunking-the-myth-that-free-will-exists-psych-you-thought/
Copyright 2026