On Sept. 16, the John R. Park Debate Society held its second annual Great Campus Debate at the Crocker Science Center. Last year, the event discussed generative AI; this year, participants debated authority over public lands.
Organizers structured the debate in a parliamentary system, allowing anyone to take the stand to speak or pose rebuttals from the opposing side. The official topic was: “On balance, states should have more authority over public lands than the federal government.”
Fostering healthy disagreement
Dr. Duncan Stewart moderated the Great Campus Debate. In an interview with the Chronicle, Stewart said he hopes to get more people to be better at engaging in productive disagreement through public discourse. “Debate is a technology of communication, specifically around disagreement or deliberation, but most importantly around understanding,” Duncan said. “I think it’s important for people without debate training to come and experience a debate situation where they can experience that understanding part.”
Throughout the debate, speakers were able to chime in with arguments either affirming or opposing the proposition. Without interruption, speakers had four minutes to conduct speeches supporting their positions. After they were done, members of the debate could cross examine the speaker with clarifying questions.
In an interview with the Chronicle, Juan Boscan, a student at the university who participated in the debate, said the debate was a worthwhile experience. “A lot of the time, you go to class, but you never really get to hear what someone has to say about a broader topic,” Boscan said. “I think it brings a cool opportunity for people to come and talk in a good, civic way and have discourse and expose ideas that otherwise you don’t have the opportunity to hear.”
More than a debate
The debaters delved into subjects such as government spending, national park protections and water rights. Each member of the debate had their own focuses, each relating back to the topic at hand.
Another student who posed arguments in front of the floor was Nathan Keoppel. “There’s such a beauty in having a moderated, organized debate, because usually when you talk about politics, people get super angry,” Keoppel told the Chronicle. “I didn’t see anyone who came in here and walked out obviously looking disillusioned or something. I think everyone felt like it was pretty cool.”
As the debate wrapped up, Stewart asked participants what they got out of the experience. Some said they gained more knowledge about the subject. Others said they learned how to engage peacefully with others in a somewhat turbulent time for disagreement.
Jake Scott, a student and member of the John R. Park Debate Society, described the debate as a positive challenge. “Getting up in a room of all these people is intimidating. You know people are disagreeing with you,” he told the Chronicle. “It’s hard. The fact that there are people giving speeches, people asking questions, people confronting others was proof that it was a success.”
The Chronicle asked Scott what aspect of the debate was his favorite. “It’s really just a part of getting into the community and creating these discussions where people can interact with each other,” he said. “Because ultimately that’s how we create change, by people interacting with each other.”
j.downward@dailyutahchronicle.com
The post John R. Park Debate Society discusses federal and state lands appeared first on The Daily Utah Chronicle.