Opinion: The UMN’s new personal device and homework policy is insulting to student employees

Originally Posted on The Minnesota Daily via UWIRE

This fall, Housing and Residential Life implemented a new policy for office assistants stating they can no longer do homework or use personal devices while on the clock, excluding overnight shifts (12 a.m.-6 a.m.).

In a statement from senior director for HRL Susan Stubblefield, the policy was changed “to ensure our team delivers attentive, high-quality customer service to residents and guests; day and evening desk shifts will focus on primary desk responsibilities and customer interaction.”

It’s a nice thought, trying to show customers more consideration. However, doing so by eliminating one of the largest benefits for employees begs the question: Going forward, will there be enough incentive to fill those positions in the first place?

No one would expect a simple campus job to be lucrative. However, given the current cost of living, $15.25 an hour without the possibility of full-time employment with benefits seems hardly worth the trouble. Downward pressure has been increasing for student workers, having not received a systemic minimum wage increase since October 2022.

For years, the incentive to opt for lower-paying jobs on campus, rather than higher-paying jobs off campus, has been the more favorable work-life balance they provide. These roles can offer students distinct advantages not found at other jobs, such as guaranteed authorized leave during exams or better forms of recourse in hostile work environments. 

Crucially, it’s standard practice for campus jobs to allow students to complete homework once their immediate responsibilities are met. Eliminating that privilege undermines the relationship between student workers and HRL, which has served as a model employer by fostering an environment built around job flexibility.

University second-year Maisie Wright, who spent this past summer working as an office assistant at the front desk of Frontier Hall and helping with Special Olympics events, said the policy has already prompted many of her former coworkers to quit. 

According to Wright, this worker shortage has only been mitigated because HRL has been able to reallocate workers from the recently closed Bailey Hall to other sites.

Without that, HRL may have been forced to reverse their decision before the year even started. 

Regardless, this new policy feels like an unfortunate continuation of a recent downward trend for the University as a whole, marked by an increasingly mistrustful attitude toward students. 

Since the advent of artificial intelligence and other technologies that have destabilized the classroom, half of every syllabus day has become dedicated to redundant speeches on scholastic integrity and plagiarism. Every assignment must be submitted with full version history viewable, and attendance for every lecture is enforced by a questionnaire on some awful, buggy website like ChimeIn or iClicker.

This type of micromanaging simply does not reflect well on the University. Of course, the parameters for scholastic integrity need to be firm, but it’s the manner in which these expectations are communicated that underscores the kind of institution the University represents.

Is it one where students can be trusted or not?

In the context of the HRL policy, it’s common sense that job duties take precedence over homework during working hours. If that needs to be enforced by a blanket ban on personal devices, that’s not a reflection on students’ capacity to balance their responsibilities, but a reflection on the kinds of students the University admits in the first place.

It’s doubtful that the Ivy League schools believe their students would fail to show up to class without mandatory attendance or be incapable of managing more than one device while working a clerical-type job. This is why, even if the policy is not heavily enforced, the fact that it was created in the first place reflects a growing disconnect between students and administrators.

Allegedly, there has already been friction within HRL about this.

“I heard from higher-ups who are going to continue working this fall that a lot of management really doesn’t want to enforce it because this isn’t something that they came up with,” Wright said. “It was from deeper within the Housing and Residential administration.” 

A fourth-year student and current dorm office assistant, who spoke anonymously with the Minnesota Daily for fear of retaliation from his employer, concurred. They said that their manager has yet to enforce the policy change, nor discuss it with them or their coworkers since it was first announced via email two months ago.

The student went on to say that desk workers are continuing to do homework at the desks, albeit more discreetly. Some office associates have stopped wearing headphones for fear of being seen on camera and reprimanded.

Keeping employees in this state of limbo and pitting the authority of upper and lower management against each other is unsustainable. To quickly settle these tensions, it may be wise for the policy’s authors to defer to the judgement of their more junior employees. 

However, if they wish to stand behind their decision, then their employees should be compensated accordingly. It’s unreasonable to increase the burden on their employees without reflecting this added expectation in their pay.

The reality is that this policy likely does not have much life remaining, having immediately received public backlash, such as Students for a Democratic Society calling it pointless and anti-student on social media, while also being inherently difficult to enforce. 

Yet, as long as it’s on the books, it will continue posing an unnecessary risk to student workers’ job security, as well as reinforce an increasingly mistrustful University culture.

The post Opinion: The UMN’s new personal device and homework policy is insulting to student employees appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.

Read more here: https://mndaily.com/opinion/opinion-the-umns-new-personal-device-and-homework-policy-is-insulting-to-student-employees/09/14/2026/eicmndaily-com/
Copyright 2026 The Minnesota Daily