As a junior in high school, I remember sitting in the back of the classroom with my friends, pretending to take notes on our laptops while secretly watching World Cup matches. This year, the tournament didn’t have that same thrill.
Why? Let’s start with the obvious.
One, a Super Bowl-style halftime show. Shakira, BTS, Justin Bieber, and somehow Kermit the Frog and the Muppets, took the stage during the championship game at MetLife Stadium in New Jersey. The New York Times called it “a parody of the American sporting experience,” with “no story being told.”
Two, hydration breaks. U.S. Women’s National Team coach Emma Hayes called the new three-minute stops in play “momentum breaks” that inadvertently gave whatever team was losing time to regroup. Netherlands defender Virgil van Dijk said the breaks were “not great” for fans watching at home.
Three, ticket prices. A Category 1 seat for the opening match cost $2,735, more than four times what the same tier cost in Qatar in 2022. Euroconsumers and Football Supporters Europe, both consumer and football advocacy groups, filed an official complaint against the Federation Internationale de Football Association (FIFA), claiming it “abused its monopoly position” over ticket sales.
Four, commercials. FIFA has called itself a nonprofit for years, a label that lets it avoid being taxed like a corporation. Although FIFA President Gianni Infantino stated the commercial breaks did not generate additional revenue, ironically, FIFA reported roughly $9 billion in tournament revenue this year alone.
These American ideals of capitalism and profitization were forcefully inserted into a tournament that didn’t ask for this level of commercialism. Ultimately, money came before the game.
But above all, I believe the imposition of an ill-fitting American lens onto a global tournament is what ruined the World Cup.
The United States has its unique political history and racial dynamics. Other countries have their own. However, when certain American vocabulary gets thrust onto an international stage as culturally diverse as the World Cup, nations risk being stripped of their own identity and judged through a political framework foreign to their own.
Inevitably, Argentina became the scapegoat.
During the Round of 16 match between Argentina and Egypt, Egypt led 2-0 in the 67th minute, but then Argentina surged — scoring three times in the final 11 minutes and stoppage time, securing a 3-2 comeback win. The media cycle started with people claiming the game was rigged, pointing to a disallowed Egypt goal under Video Assistance Referee review as proof the referees were paid off, even though FIFA Referees Committee Chairman Pierluigi Collina backed the referee’s calls as correct.
But then things escalated. All over social media, posts about how racist Argentina is spread like wildfire, resulting in extreme, unhinged comparisons like American streamer Sneako’s tweet that “Argentina is the Israel of South America.”
Rather than researching the context behind the topic at hand, Americans online were quick to run with a narrative of racism and oppression and eagerly forced it upon Argentina. All it took were a few TikToks and Instagram Reels to convince people that they understood an entire country. The algorithm reinforced the same conclusion over and over, while people bandwagoned behind a narrative they were uneducated about.
That is the danger of viewing a global event through a distinctly American political lens. Understanding another country requires learning about its history and culture on their own terms, rather than assuming the political vocabulary used in the U.S. can be applicable anywhere abroad. Through ignorance, the media interpreted an already-complex situation through a framework that didn’t fit.
Argentine journalist Pedro Rosemblat said the judgment was coming from people “who would not be able to explain anything about our history, our society and our civilization.” He specifically pointed to American and European audiences judging Argentina despite their own histories of racism, colonization, war and xenophobia.
In fact, many Argentines acknowledged and condemned racist chants from players and fans as well as the history of racism in their country. What they rejected was the stigmatization of their entire nation and national team because of it.
If that is the standard, why wasn’t England or Spain labeled racist for their own histories of colonialism? Are we just going to forget America’s history of slavery? We could certainly label several other countries as racist with this framing. But see how ridiculous this becomes? This never-ending political blame game is overreaching and exhausting.
The issue isn’t whether racism or injustice exists. Of course they do. It’s how casually and selectively American media throw around these accusations, become desensitized to their weight, and miss the bigger picture when they fit a familiar narrative.
We’ve become so accustomed to seeing everything through the political vocabulary of our own country that we forget the rest of the world doesn’t necessarily speak the same language.
The purpose of the World Cup is to unite countries around the world through the sport of soccer. To preserve the spirit and camaraderie that makes the World Cup special, we must learn to see the world through a lens beyond our own.