A new U.S. Department of Education rule aims to decrease student loan debt in higher education, which now total $1.7 trillion, but may limit grant eligibility for students seeking degrees with low-earning job prospects.
College of Education Department Head Jerry Rosiek called the new rules another layer of “consumer protection” for young people looking at education options. Several UO professors agree, but are also skeptical about what the ED values in higher education.
“On one hand, I totally think protecting students from excessive debt is important; but the metrics being used here are focused on earnings, and there’s lots of other values and life paths that are not captured,” Colin Ives, incoming department head for the School of Art and Design, said.
How the metrics work
If college graduates with bachelor’s degrees are not earning more than their high school-educated counterparts in the same field of study, students in low-earning programs might not be eligible to receive direct federal loans. The new rule is expected to take effect in July 2027.
Students in a school’s program that does not meet earning metrics two out of three consecutive years would likely be ineligible for federal direct loans and Title IV loans, including Pell Grants, are also at risk if the program fails a third year. The metrics for student earnings are calculated four years after the students graduate, according to the ED.
For UO, the metrics would likely look at state earnings versus national earnings in the chosen field of study because more than 50% of UO’s students are in-state.
This isn’t the first time the ED has changed its guidelines on student loan restrictions. Most of the guidance the department is overhauling is 2019 regulations, which restricted loans based on what percentage of student borrowers’ income could be dedicated toward paying off student loans.
In its published rule, the department reasoned that the new rules upheld consistency across higher education, but said the recent changes may leave students vulnerable to private lenders with higher interest rates.
What is valued in education
In an email to The Daily Emerald, UO Spokesperson Angela Seydel said, “It’s too soon to know exactly which programs, if any, would fail the measure,” but some UO professors are hesitant about focusing only on earning outcomes.
Ives said that looking at earnings a few years after graduation might not provide the federal government with the full picture because there is no one “straight career path to success in the long term.”
Ives pointed out examples of teaching students who have dabbled in various fields and jobs before finding a true passion.
Ives said in the art department he had a student who became a pilot, another student who works at a basic needs non-profit in Springfield, and Josh Wardle, UO alumnus and creator of the Wordle game, who worked as a graduate employee in Ives’ class.
“All of these people have other jobs to make ends meet, but they have inspired regional artists and have been able to bring artists into the community,” Ives said. “Early-career earnings don’t necessarily reflect the long-term value they’ve added creatively, culturally or to the communities they’ve helped build.”
Emily Tanner-Smith, dean of the College of Education and psychology and human services professor, said she thinks the new rule could discourage students from serving in education where good teachers are needed most.
Tanner-Smith, in an email to The Emerald, said she is concerned that the new rule might “unintentionally shift attention away from (a) larger question” of why certain careers, including education, have low compensation.
“Ultimately, I support accountability and believe we need an approach that recognizes both economic outcomes and the public value of the professions our graduates enter,” Tanner-Smith said. “The challenge is designing accountability systems that protect students and taxpayers while also sustaining the workforce our schools and communities depend on.”
The post Loans to be limited by Department of Education for low-earning programs appeared first on Daily Emerald.