The Minneapolis City Council rejected a proposed contract between the Minneapolis Police Department and Skydio, a California-based drone company, citing privacy concerns.
The 75-day pilot program with Skydio would have enabled the MPD to use drones in hopes of speeding up response times. However, concerns over data privacy and city involvement with a federal government-contracted company drew pushback from both representatives and the public.
The Minneapolis City Council deliberated on July 16 regarding implementing the drone-piloting program in north Minneapolis. Residents packed the council chambers to maximum capacity as the Council and Mayor Jacob Frey discussed the drone-piloting program.
Council member LaTrisha Vetaw (Ward 4) said her constituents are asking for more protection in their neighborhoods, and this pilot program would be able to help aid in that.
“Since the day I was elected, I made a commitment to solve the problems they face,” Vetaw said. “Faster police response times, cleaner streets and less violent crime. Year after year, I had to tell them that we cannot make the progress they deserve because we do not have enough officers on our streets. I am tired of saying that.”
Vetaw said the Skydio drones would reduce police response times.
“Police response time in the fourth precinct is more than seven minutes,” Vetaw said. “With this pilot, response time could be reduced to under two minutes. So far, this year, there have been more than 7,800 calls where this technology could have been deployed. Roughly 40 calls every day.”
However, council members raised concerns about surveillance and Skydio’s history working with the Israel Defense Forces and the federal government.
Council member Aurin Chowdhury had concerns following Minneapolis’ experience during Operation Metro Surge.
“We cannot go through an ICE occupation and say f-ICE, turn around and then build out our surveillance state with the company that is working with ICE,” Chowdhury said. “The same organization that killed our neighbors, brutalized our community and surveilled each and every one of us.”
According to Vetaw, Skydio’s business relationships should not trump the needs of Minneapolis residents.
“The outcome of this decision hinges on whether a country halfway around the world purchases equipment from the same company does not make sense to me,” Vetaw said. “I do not believe that this is a responsible basis for deciding whether our residents should have access to a tool that can improve public safety.”
Council member Jason Chavez raised questions around privacy and data protection. He questioned whether the data officers gather could potentially be relayed back to ICE.
“Did the Minneapolis Police Department do any due diligence on Skydio’s contracts? Do they sell drones to ICE or other Department of Human Services?” Chavez said.
Minneapolis Police Sergeant Roger Moua said the department had conducted research on Skydio and found no concerns. He also believes questioning the background of every law enforcement tool is a moot point.
“Prior to looking into Skydio, we did our due diligence,” Moua said. “If we were to look at every other company that we’re also associated with difficult types of technologies or tools, we wouldn’t be able to get anywhere at all.”
Skydio currently works with other Minnesota cities, such as St. Paul, according to MPR.
Moua said all information collected by the drones would go directly to the police department, and that no data would go back to Skydio. All data collected that is not viable in a case would be deleted after seven days.
“With regards to data collection, that was something that we were concerned about as well,” Moua said. “Our city attorneys initially reworded it that way so they would have no say in how we collect our data. We would set the parameters on how we would document these incidents.”
Lavish Mack, a resident of Ward 13, said he was surprised at how close the vote came.
“I’m mind blown by the 6-6 tie that it would even be that close. I thought it was going to be 7-5. I thought 8-4, but there’s a couple paid and bought for city council members,” Mack said.
Council member Pearll Warren said Americans are already on camera several times a day, so it shouldn’t make a difference.
“Someone is always watching what’s going on walking down the street, no one is asking where that information is stored,” Warren said. “We have serious things at stake here that we’re trying to work on to build better for our communities. Drones don’t shoot at people, they’re not listening to your conversations, they’re going to report incidents. I’m just asking for lifesaving opportunities.”
The post Minneapolis City Council strikes down controversial police contract with drone pilot program appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.