Gracie Abrams’ ‘Daughter from Hell’ needs more hell

Originally Posted on The Triangle via UWIRE

Photo by Rocco Fonseca | The Triangle

“Daughter from Hell” is an album title that promises chaos, anger, maybe even a little fun. It evokes images of rebellion and catharsis. Gracie Abrams’ third studio album delivers pretty much none of that.

Instead, “Daughter from Hell” is remarkably subdued. Across 16 tracks, Abrams delivers whispered vocals, muted acoustic production, and self-doubt, all delivered with such strong restraint that all the songs blur together. It is cohesive, sure, but cohesion alone cannot carry an album this long. For a record so intent on emotional vulnerability, it rarely builds towards anything memorable. 

The album establishes that approach almost immediately. Opener “Hit the Wall” hints at something larger with its euphoric bridge before settling back into familiar territory. “Death Wish,” “The Knife,” and the title track continue with relationship metaphors and introspective lyricism, themes the album rarely escapes. Even Abrams’ strongest lyrics lose their impact when they return to the same emotional destination. By the album’s midpoint, another breakup, another episode of self-doubt, and another knife metaphor (seriously, she does not stop talking about knives) begin to feel like comfortable patterns instead of motifs. 

Much of that sameness is reinforced by Aaron Dessner’s production. It is easy to see that Taylor Swift’s “folklore” and “evermore” were on Abrams’ moodboard, two albums Dessner produced. While both those records balanced hushed, acoustic production with vivid, confessional storytelling, “Daughter from Hell” rarely does. Even “Look at My Life,” the album’s lead single, briefly suggests a sharper, more self-aware direction before the record quickly settles back into familiar territory. By the album’s midpoint, the restraint that initially felt intentional just becomes suffocating. 

Then comes “Minibar,” a clear Audrey Hobert co-write. The gist of the song is basically weird, insecure girl goes to a party, pretty much the same premise as Hobert’s “Bowling alley.” “Minibar” succeeds because of its conversational tone combined with its quirky melody. The song is undoubtedly a highlight, and a much-needed change in energy two-thirds of the way through the record. It is telling that the album’s most memorable moment is also its most unserious. But the track begs the question — why would Abrams not write more songs with Hobert for this record, especially considering Hobert is responsible for some of Abrams’ biggest hits. 

After “Minibar,” the record retreats back into its familiar formula, with overcomplex metaphors over dingy acoustic instrumentals. Towards the end of the record, Abrams’ attempts to be witty through these metaphors just become exhausting. On “Humming,” she reflects on a loss of innocence: “I don’t know love / How to live in extremes / But we’re meant to try through humming.” What does “humming” mean here? It can be fun when a song has somewhat nonsensical lyrics, but that approach does not mesh well with how serious Abrams is throughout this album. 

A notable standout in the sluggish back half is Marcus Mumford’s feature on “What If It’s Right?” Although the track lacks a spark like the rest of the songs on the record, Abrams and Mumford’s vocals genuinely work well together, repeating the catchy refrain “What If It’s Right?” 

Closer “Cold Goodbyes” ends things on an all-too-familiar reflection, this time on her fame. But by then “Daughter from Hell” has already settled too deeply into its own formula. The issue is not that Abrams writes about regret, heartbreak, or insecurities — she has built a career on those themes. But this time around, she cannot find new ways to explore them. 

For all its meticulous songwriting, “Daughter from Hell” never fully figures out its own identity. The cover, with Abrams sat staring angrily at something off camera, suggests revenge. The title promises chaos. Yet the music is simply sedating. Seriously, this album is perfect to fall asleep to. Abrams has proven before that she can write songs that are melodramatic, messy, and even a little irritating. At least those songs demanded a reaction. Here, she seems so determined to be understated and emotionally profound that the album fades quietly into the background. 

Fittingly, “Daughter from Hell” hits the wall long before it reaches hell. 

Read more here: https://thetriangle.org/article/gracie-abrams-daughter-from-hell-needs-more-hell
Copyright 2026 The Triangle