Across the state, local governments and communities grapple with corporate development plans for data centers, drawing the attention of academic researchers.
As physical manifestations of a global network of remote servers, known as the cloud, these facilities store, process and manage all of our digital data. While data centers have existed since the mid-1900s, the artificial intelligence boom demands exponentially more data storage, driving technology corporations to target towns across the U.S.
For those who work in the energy sector currently, data centers are the center of gravity, Gabe Chan, associate professor from the Hubert H. Humphrey School of Public Affairs, said.
“One of the big meta-challenges is that the energy sector is very complicated — there’s a lot of engineering, finance, economics, law and policy,” Chan said.
This complexity fuels public skepticism. Public sentiment toward data centers is increasingly negative, and it hasn’t always been this way, Chan said. Yet data center development has been eager here in Minnesota — cold winters mean lower energy costs — and sometimes, shrouded in secrecy.
“There is a need for education and capacity building so that communities can effectively engage in this technically complicated space,” Chan said.
To fill this gap, University of Minnesota researchers are deploying their expertise.
The data difficulty
Because data center infrastructure is diverse and constantly evolving, reliable third-party data is scarce. Even when companies provide environmental disclosures, the data is often insufficient or nonexistent.
University environmental economics professor Stephen Polasky said the U.S. does not have strict corporate reporting requirements that make environmental disclosures mandatory. If companies do release energy use or water consumption reports, the accuracy of those reports comes into question.
The problem is that a corporation has a vested financial interest in getting a project approved with minimal hassle, so they are unlikely to voluntarily highlight those energy and water vulnerabilities, Polasky said. Data provided by disinterested third parties is crucial to bridge this lack of transparency and trust.
“People would trust the findings of, let’s say, a report coming out of the University of Minnesota than they would from a corporation,” Polasky said.
For instance, facilities rarely specify their water consumption. When a municipality supplies the water rather than the data center drawing its own, then the challenge becomes tracking, explicitly, the data center’s use.
Hydrology professor John Nieber and Geosyntec engineer Nigel Pickering are using data centers as a case study for a state-funded project assessing the cumulative impacts of small and hyperscale facilities on local water systems.
While 20 years of state water records are available, the challenge lies in modeling the physical impact. The researchers are using LiDAR and GIS, which are mapping technologies, and Minnesota Department of Natural Resources data to map these subterranean effects.
The missing piece is transparent data from the tech companies on their exact internal water use, Pickering said, but the system could be built to ingest that data as soon as it becomes available.
“Collecting the spatial information [isn’t] going to be a big challenge,” Nieber said. “The challenge is accurately accounting for the specific behavior of individual data center designs.”
Their tool will model how data centers consume and redistribute water, transforming unknown environmental risks into quantifiable metrics so communities can make informed choices.
The public’s environmental anxiety stems from a fundamental lack of clear information regarding what the real impacts will be, which naturally instills fear, Pickering added.
“Without having some sort of knowledge of what the impacts are, they’re not gonna want the data center at all,” Pickering said.
In Minnesota, no one chooses their utility company. Some are concerned utility bills will increase due to the massive energy load data centers demand from a local grid if corporations are not paying their fair share.
“This is basic economic supply and demand,” Polasky said. “If you’re introducing massive new demands of electricity to the grid and the supply cannot keep pace, energy becomes scarcer and prices will inevitably rise.”
Polasky points to Northern Virginia and the mid-Atlantic states, where hyper-concentration has strained the grid and inflated consumer utility bills.
The equipped community
“Communities weigh these decisions all the time, figuring out whether to allow developments or not,” Polasky said.
While offering attractive municipal tax revenues and short-term construction jobs, data centers also present complex burdens: industrial noise, infrastructure strain and long-term maintenance, said Polasky.
Seeking guidance, three southern Minnesota municipalities facing regional data center expansions approached the Regional Sustainable Development Partnership, routing the request to Humphrey School assistant professor Elise Harrington.
“They came to us saying, ‘We need better information on how local government should be thinking about this,’” Harrington said.
Cities know how to make decisions for themselves, but, traditionally, local governments rarely engage deeply with matters of electricity and utility, said Harrington.
Harrington and University law professor James Coleman are analyzing data center development around the country to create a decision-making toolkit for local leaders.
“Our role is not to advocate that local governments should be for or against data centers, but that they need the best information to make the right decision in close collaboration and coordination with their own residents and their own community members,” Harrington said.
Designed as a customizable menu of options, the toolkit overlays a data-center lens onto existing municipal frameworks like land use, zoning and moratoria. However, because cities lack authority over major utilities, asking the right questions is vital. Water metrics are intuitive for cities operating local water utilities, Harrington noted, but navigating the electricity sector remains a significant blind spot.
“It’s important for any local government to know: here are the issues that are being raised about data centers in different ways, pro and con,” Harrington said. “So that you’re prepared to have those conversations, but also prepared to ask really good questions to everyone involved in the process.”
The role of trust
The goal of this research is not to stop data center development, said Nieber. Instead, the intent is a deeper understanding of the environmental impact.
“What we want to do is to take an unbiased view and go in there and look at it scientifically, and come up with a result that we can defend before the public,” said Nieber.
“Data centers are sort of a flashpoint,” Polasky said. “People are largely mistrusting large corporations and big government in general.”
Harrington conceptualizes these challenges as information-based and relationship-based uncertainties. Information gaps — like baseline water and power consumption — can be resolved through independent research.
Academic research alone, though, cannot repair corporate-civil relationships, Harrington said, and one research project perhaps isn’t sufficient to answer all the questions people have about data centers.
“I hope that it provides some amount of transparency so that different folks within this can talk about some of the same things,” Harrington said. “Yet relationship-based uncertainty relies entirely on public discourse, relationships and trust.”
While data alone may not solve the crisis of trust, independent research ensures communities do not navigate this boom in the dark.
“Figuring out the right response is a really important challenge for those who care about the environment, local government and deeply care about public processes and democracy,” Harrington said.
The post Data centers are ‘flashpoint’ that UMN researchers are helping Minnesota navigate appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.