
With extreme right-wing rhetoric on the rise, there has been a drastic pushback against the progress made by the body-positivity movement, and the topics of weight and beauty standards have become more political than they already were.
However, attempts to counter skinny culture by simply promoting different traits as beautiful are likely to fail; all it ends up doing is reinforcing the culture that prioritizes being beautiful as well as the personal impulse to achieve beauty. Cultures that value aesthetic beauty tend to also value submission, and skinny is the visual cue of submissiveness. So, when something like a “male loneliness epidemic” occurs from the growing self-esteem vacuum propagated by overexposure to instant sexual stimulation, they demand the same from their women. Skinny, hairless, and most importantly, young bodies, are fast food to the compounding insecurities of the modern American man.
A combination of medical and sociological research tells us that conventionally attractive traits that are not associated with fertility are typically of a random social origin. Skinniness does not signal health or fertility. Conventional moral principles tend to punish women who do not prioritize their appeal. Skinniness is visual conformity. Submissive women are less available than they were traditionally, so anything besides “skinny” is a threat to infinite accessible gratification.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, a lot of us would come to find out how inconvenient and stressful it was to be seen in any capacity. With visual presentation fully in our own control, people unanimously drifted towards facelessness. Being caught not abiding to the typical classroom standard seemed only part of the reason. I had never realized how much of a relief it could be to hide on days I did not feel beautiful; this ended up becoming every day since I had the easy option to disconnect from my own appearance. Whether we knew it or not, everyone was fatigued from the pressures of beauty culture.
That is one of the only luxuries that popular celebrities do not have, and their public identities illustrate pop culture’s most relevant insecurities. The matter of their beauty—whether they have it or do not, whether it is maintained or lost—becomes the point of fixation. Physical perfection becomes immunity from scrutiny. And it is undeniable what mainstream culture considers perfection. Her image is plastered everywhere. A young, high cheek-bone white woman with curves and a maximum four dress size.
But of course, it is also not women’s responsibility to manage the weight of the social torture that comes from being fat: the desire for someone to tell you that you are beautiful is a natural response to a culture that does not really care about anything else.
Except it actually is if she wants to have a manageable life.
When Ariana Grande and her appeared malnourished during the press tour for “Wicked,” the movie was guaranteed seats.
It was not only their appearances that were disturbing, but the way the promotional material seemed to intentionally highlight their most anorexic features. In promotional content, the actresses are posed flexing their necks and jaws, with their hands on their shoulders to make their collar bones protrude. The dresses they wore were cut to expose their very prominent sternums with little gems placed as an accent by the most visible bone.
People responded with mockery, outrage, misogyny, racism, concern, but what every conversation turned into was: does this make Grande a bad person?
Every single attempt at conversations about the scrutiny that female celebrities face cycles back to “well, what are they actually responsible for?” And most energy gets devoted to dissecting the actions of the celebrity, looking for the nuances of the hatred they receive. Then, conversations that focus on moving past this mindset must devote themselves to undoing the language that was supposed to bring awareness to these problems.
In Grande’s case, people are trying to figure out when a vulnerable, young teenage girl shaped by online eating disorder culture on sites like Tumblr, whose boss was a pedophile, and was raised among other pedophile executives became an irresponsible international sensation, responsible for her own influence, purposeful or not. Why did she not handle it in a more responsible way? Does she know she is influential? Does she know that underage girls look up to her?
On that same press tour, a video of her at 15-years-old began to circulate around the internet in which she is being abused by Dan Schneider. The abuse Grande has publicly endured was sidelined in conversation to focus on her weight. Whether it is an actual concern or not, all it accomplishes in the current way of things is a critique of how efficiently and politically correctly they are able to overcome and defy institutional abuse. What is ultimately being argued is whether Grande has a right to be anorexic, and if she does, whether this dictates her right to her professional roles.
Meanwhile, that video still circulates, which, unfortunately, anyone is able to watch whenever they feel like. But maybe when millions of people have laughed at, come around to, denied, rejected, and politicized, not only evidence of, but an actual recording of her abuse, you learn how to deal with it, regardless of whether a human brain is actually capable of processing the scale of such a violation as that.
As long as culture is obsessed with physical beauty, mainstream beauty standards will continue to favor thinness and submission. Because obsession with aesthetic beauty, particularly of women, has conservative priorities. Distance from aesthetic beauty over simply changing the standard could enable actual freedom, instead of openings on a sexual menu. Hollywood is built on the promise of a transcendentally sexual female form. It relies on the quick satisfaction and expectations of its male audiences and the creative ability of its male executives to navigate this, which is probably why so many of the most beloved movies are about the mental torture of being unable to reconcile with hypersexuality and hypermasculinity. Movies like “Fight Club,” “Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind,” and “American Psycho” all circle this idea. Most people do not have the patience to unlearn beauty standards on their own, and most of Hollywood’s investors do not want to gamble with audience favor.
When people bring so much urgency to the condition of these women and not far more outrageous conditions they have been subjected to, they are not addressing the root issue. Instead, they bring attention to the appearance of the celebrity—not their mental state. It only highlights the very product that Hollywood has been selling. Rather than boycotting it, attention gets reinvested, giving the industry more reason to perpetuate it, and the power it needs to dictate what beauty is.