Editorial: Charter of Hope

By Daily Californian Editorial Board

Berkeley is well-known for its strong commitment to social justice – a reputation we believe is worth of defending. Sadly, sometimes that penchant for social justice reaches counterproductive extremes. The recent battle over the establishment of charter schools displayed that dark side. Fortunately, more reasonable minds prevailed.

Last Wednesday, the Berkeley Unified School District (BUSD) Board of Education approved a proposal to create the Revolutionary Education and Learning Movement (REALM) grade 6-12 public charter school. While an original proposal fell short because it was believed not to meet state requirements, we praise the proponents of the charter school for going back to the drawing board and fixing the proposal.

This proposal was strongly opposed by the activist group BAMN. BAMN alleged that this school would resegregate Berkeley public education, creating an overwhelmingly minority-populated school.

BAMN’s speculative contention is based on the fact the school would be exempt from the district-wide desegregation plan. In the case of demand for admission exceeding open spots at the school, REALM would admit by lottery, rather than under the direction of Berkeley’s race and socioeconomic status-based system.

BAMN’s claims of segregation ignore the true history of the practice – minority and white students were prohibited from attending the same schools. Charter schools are voluntary, and no child, minority or otherwise, will be forced to attend them as opposed to a regular BUSD school. Charter schools only give parents more choice, not less, about the kind of educational environment their children will learn in.

The gap in educational success between Berkeley’s white student and black and Hispanic students is an embarrassment to the city. Charter schools are an innovative way to give students access to educational approaches that are not possible in traditional public schools. We are uncertain that these approaches will always be successful, but considering the poor job Berkeley’s educational system has done for many minority youth, they ought to be explored.

Read more here: http://www.dailycal.org/article/109642/charter_of_hope
Copyright 2026 Daily Californian