Do you know the history of the buildings you walk into every day?
Seven years ago, a cohort of academics and students assembled a task force to urge the University of Minnesota Board of Regents to change buildings with controversial names. Despite a years-long battle, Nicholson Hall remains the only building renamed.
Nicholson Hall, now known as 216 Pillsbury Hall, awaits a formal title at a nameless standstill — the Board never got past removing its former name.
Coffman Union, Nicholson Hall, Middlebrook Hall and Coffey Hall, the other 3 buildings recommended in the task force report, have also remained untouched since the Task Force on Building Names and Institutional History Report.
During her time as University Student Body President in 2017, Trish Palmero fervently advocated for the name changing of University buildings. Nine years later, Palermo presented a solution that solves the problem of relevancy, which she revealed in a statement to the Minnesota Daily.
“Coffman is a center for students to be inspired and build community,” Palermo said in the statement. “The building should be named after Melissa Hortman, a University of Minnesota alumna who dedicated her life to serving this state and giving back in every way she could and who represents everything we can hope for from UMN students. Being the namesake of such a building is an honor, and we should honor her.”
Former University professor Riv-Ellen Prell spearheaded “A Campus Divided,” an exhibit that debuted at the Elmer L. Andersen Library in 2017 to shed light on controversial building names. Now, the exhibit exists as a permanent digital display of archived documents, essays and interactive features that explore the University’s history of surveillance and segregation.
Coffman Union, the University’s student hub, was named after former president, Lotus Coffman, who served from 1920 until his death in 1938. As the fifth president, Coffman’s vision for the University was campus expansion, but marginalized groups were excluded.
To Coffman, segregated housing and special privileges for white students were the keys to success, according to “A Campus Divided.” In a letter to the head of the Minneapolis NAACP, Lena Olive Smith, Coffman wrote that white students and students of color had no business together.
“The races have never lived together nor have they ever sought to live together,” Coffman wrote in 1931.
The regents revoked Nicholson Hall’s honorary naming in 2024, 5 years later.
According to “A Campus Divided,” former Dean Edward Nicholson controlled what mail could be delivered on campus and which student groups could freely organize, and influenced the leadership of the Minnesota Daily.
Prell said Nicholson, a Red Scare believer, went to meticulous lengths to control speech. Nicholson leaked information about student group activities to the Board of Regents, who were heavily anti-communist at the time.
“I finally got to the 1929 files where Nicholson was sending his own secretary to go to any left-wing student meeting on campus,” Prell said. “He would approve the groups, he would say they could meet at a University building, but then he sent people to spy on them.”
In an April 2019 Board meeting, the University voted against renaming the four buildings in a 10-1 landslide. Abdul Omari was the sole agreer.
As the only Black regent, Omari said he felt estranged.
Omari acknowledged the question shared by his fellow regents: how do we judge people based on their era in the past when we weren’t there? He raised a simple solution.
“The more problematic thing I think comes in is when people are putting names on buildings because they’re given a bunch of money,” Omari said. “Just call it [said buildings] ‘the student union’ and ‘the biology building’.”
Prell said the fall-off of renaming efforts was a part of a broader crisis in higher education. In between national crises like COVID-19 and conflict in Gaza, she said she did not blame University administration or the student and faculty body for failing to get up to speed.
“The Trump administration began to weaponize antisemitism and threaten to harm and destroy Universities if they did not toe the line, if they did not forbid speech, if they did not disallow it, they would take away millions of dollars in grants,” Prell said. “I am deeply sympathetic that building names are not quite as powerful as they were a few years ago.”
The post What happened to renaming Coffman Memorial Union? appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.